Broward County commissioners are considering a land use
amendment that would move a major Margate redevelopment proposal into state
review. The item, listed on the May 26th County Commission agenda, would
transmit the proposed amendment to designated state agencies for review
 under Florida’s comprehensive
planning process. The action does not approve construction. It sends the
proposed map change to state and regional agencies for comments before a later
adoption decision.
The amendment applies to about 81.7 acres in Margate,
generally south of Sample Road between Rock Island Road and Holiday Springs
Boulevard. The site is part of the former Carolina Club golf course. Current
county land use designations identify 75.1 acres as Recreation and Open Space
and 6.6 acres as Commercial Recreation. The proposed amendment would
redesignate 74.1 acres for Irregular (7) Residential use and 7.6 acres for
Commerce within the same dashed-line area.
The applicant, Rosemurgy Acquisitions, LLC, proposes up
to 540 two-story townhomes and up to 24,800 square feet of neighborhood-serving
commercial space. The commercial portion could include retail, restaurant, or
medical office uses. The property owner is listed as J & D Golf Properties,
LLC. The City of Margate recommends approval of the amendment.
County planning records describe the golf course as a
long-standing recreational property that closed in 2019 after years of
declining play and rising operating costs. The applicant states that earlier
attempts to revive the golf operation did not succeed. That history is
important because the land is no longer functioning as an active golf course,
even as its current land use designation still reflects recreation-based use.
The proposal would not add new dwelling-unit capacity to
the broader Carolina Club dashed-line area. County documents state that the
636.2-acre area already permits 4,453 dwelling units. About 3,383 units exist,
leaving 1,070 unbuilt units. The proposed 540 townhomes would use part of that
existing remaining capacity rather than increase the total number of units
allowed under the Broward County Land Use Plan.
That point matters to taxpayers because new development
can create demand for public services. County planning staff found that
adequate potable water, sanitary sewer, drainage, and solid waste capacity will
be available to serve the proposed land use. Since the residential units
already fit within the existing dwelling-unit allowance, the county review
treats the residential component differently from a project that would add new
regional housing capacity.
Transportation remains one of the most important public
cost questions. The unrestricted version of the amendment was projected to add
about 380 p.m. peak-hour trips to the regional transportation network. After
the applicant submitted a draft restrictive covenant limiting the project to
540 dwelling units and 24,800 square feet of commercial use, the projected
increase dropped to about 296 p.m. peak-hour trips. County analysis found that
the restricted proposal is not expected to negatively affect regional
transportation operating conditions.
The applicant also proposes to preserve about 67 gross
acres, or 65.3 net acres, of the remaining golf course as private park use for
the Carolina Club community. Planning Council staff recognized that commitment
in recommending approval. The applicant’s plan describes new lakes, a
recreation trail, pocket parks, exercise equipment, and a dog park. The
proposed open space would remain under a Recreation and Open Space designation.
The parks issue has a direct taxpayer angle. Margate
currently has about 294.59 acres of parks and open space, while the city’s
projected 2050 population requires about 193.85 acres under the county standard
of three acres per thousand residents. County staff concluded that the city’s
park inventory calculation remains unchanged even with the loss of 81.7 acres
of golf course acreage, because enough golf course acreage would remain
available elsewhere in the city to count toward the requirement.
The private park commitment could reduce pressure on
taxpayers because the city would not have to buy and maintain that land as a
public park. At the same time, private park space does not provide the same
public access as a city park. That makes the deed restrictions, maintenance
obligations, and long-term enforcement important issues as the project moves
through review.
Environmental review may become a central part of the
debate. County environmental staff found that the site may contain
jurisdictional wetlands, which means a wetland determination is required before
land clearing or filling. If wetlands or surface waters are affected, the
applicant must obtain an Environmental Resource License before site work.
The former golf course also raises contamination
concerns. County environmental review identified the site as land with a high
potential for arsenic contamination due to its golf course history. The
applicant provided Phase I and Phase II environmental assessments. The Broward
County Environmental Permitting Division determined that the site is
contaminated and requires an Environmental Assessment and Remediation License,
along with cleanup before environmental review approval for construction plans.
Environmental cleanup must remain the developer’s
responsibility. If contamination is not properly addressed before construction,
public agencies and nearby residents could face long-term consequences through
monitoring, enforcement, drainage concerns, or future remediation disputes. The
county’s current review places cleanup obligations on the applicant before
construction approvals can move forward.
The applicant’s fiscal case focuses on new revenue. The
amendment report cites an economic impact study stating that the project would
generate $3.28 million in one-time fees to Margate and $7.29 million in annual
city revenue once complete. The report also cites $218,000 in one-time revenue
and $4.87 million in annual revenue to the county and other governmental
agencies. Those numbers come from the applicant’s submission, so they should be
weighed against public service demands, infrastructure impacts, and long-term
maintenance expectations.
The School Board review also affects the taxpayer
discussion. A prior analysis based on a larger unit count estimated 220
additional students. The report states that Margate Elementary, Margate Middle,
and Coral Springs High were under-enrolled in the 2024-2025 school year and
were expected to remain below the adopted level of service through the
2026-2027 school year. The residential units will still be subject to school
concurrency review at the plat or site plan stage.
The Broward County Planning Council staff recommended
approval on April 14, 2026. On April 23, 2026, the Planning Council voted 14-0
to recommend approval without requiring a second Planning Council public
hearing. If county commissioners transmit the amendment, state agencies can
review the proposal before a final adoption decision.