Entertainment over meritocracy in LIV fallout

Entertainment over meritocracy in LIV fallout

As many as 34 players who were part of LIV Golf at some stage will hold DP World Tour status next year. That number seems incredibly bloated considering the now dead disruptor league openly tried to destroy those at Wentworth HQ.

Some LIV players were always destined to return to the DP World Tour full time, either through exemptions, continuing to obtain membership on both tours or by the settling of fines with Guy Kinnings and co. To have secured the returns of Jon Rahm, Tyrrell Hatton and then the coup of Bryson DeChambeau will be seen as an overall positive thing for the DP World Tour while Dustin Johnson, Cameron Smith, Bubba Watson and Joaquin Niemann receiving a “specific number” of tournament invitations will beef up lower ranked events as per their conditions.

Sponsors and television rights holders will be beaming over this, as will European golf fans and the head honchos at the Tour. It promises to be such an exciting season. But the rank and file DP World Tour members and those with lower categories could miss out on crucial starts.

The first event of the 2027 is next week and it is fantastic to see both Liam Nolan, who is embarking on his debut campaign, and Tom McKibbin in the field for the Australian PGA Championship. But what is alarming is that among the LIV returnees are a lot of players who have been invited to the DP World Tour and into events who simply have not earned the right to play.

Invitations for the Aussie PGA include Michael La Sasso who failed to progress from the second stage of Q-School. While Thomas Pieters failed at the Final Stage of Q-School and Carlos Ortiz and Caleb Surratt have no affiliation with the DP World Tour.

It is hard to argue against former LIV players competing on the DP World Tour under existing exemption categories but for the likes of La Sasso, who won LIV’s last ever event in Indianapolis and is part of the cohort of players which includes, Ortiz, Pieters Abraham Ancer and former Irish Open winner Lucas Herbert, this is ridiculous.

How can players like La Sasso, Ortiz and Ancer who have no affiliation with the tour be given status to compete?

LIV players took the easy money to play on a tour where nothing was earned. Some, to their credit, tried to make way through Q-School. Two earned cards, most did not progress. Like so many other players in the world who tried to qualify, they failed. That’s sport, that’s meritocracy. They should not be given invites to essentially play a season on the DP World Tour, that’s not fair. That is not earning your way in the game.

La Sasso’s name is one that will garner lots of irk from DP World Tour members. The world number 293 has only played in one major tournament. Prior to his win, the 22-year-old did not have a top ten finish and had a string of poor performances on LIV. If La Sasso is good enough he could play on the smaller tours and earn his way up. With $5m won on LIV he could surely afford to slum it.

The other way to look at it is LIV 2.0 was doomed whether it existed or not. The big names had left -except Bryson- but one thing to wonder is if the DP World Tour decided to be ruthless and kill off the league altogether by hoovering up its lesser names.

But the DPWT had already won so was it actually necessary to take the deadwood from LIV and supplement their own fields to the detriment of rank and file members? Charles Howell III wanting in won’t move the needle any more than an Eddie Pepperell, a Brandon Robinson-Thompson, or a Ewen Ferguson etc.

How the next few seasons play out is uncertain, but we could see fields with up to 20 players who have not fundamentally earned their right to be on the tour because of their performances over the last twelve months.

The Legends category created in 2018 now looks too big. 15 players are listed for 2027 including ten returning LIV players like 2010 US Open champion Graeme McDowell who hasn’t made a DP World Tour appearance since Wentworth in 2022. There weren’t many fans turning out to see these “legends” when they were on LIV…

The big name LIV players filling entry lists is a win for Guy Kinnings, even if it does push players relying on starts and even some invites themselves, further down the ladder.

When it comes to events, tournaments sponsors, the public and television want the big names, they want the “eyeballs” which will become the new buzz word for men’s professional golf. It appears they are siding towards sport as entertainment rather than a meritocracy.

Take last year’s BMW International Open in Germany, there was a Youtuber in the field named Brad Dalke. It is rumoured that Peter Finch will tee it up in Mauritius this season. The best these guys can hope for is to make the cut, they are a sideshow to the main event. Going down this route and inviting social media stars is still taking one spot away from someone who could desperately need the opportunity.

The PGA Tour is taking a meritocratic approach to 2028 where they will have 120 player fields in their top tier events with no invites. It appears on this side of the Atlantic it’s edging towards more of an entertainment product.

Add a comment

Leave a Reply