Was Bryson trying to cheat or was his 2 shot penalty a Bad Decision?
Get Golf Gear Here ▶ https://www.playbetter.com/MrShortGame
USE CODE: MRSHORTGAME
Golf Forever Here ▶ https://golfforever.pxf.io/MRSHORTGAME
GET 15% Off USE CODE: MRSHORTGAME
Subscribe to our Newsletter Here ▶ https://mailchi.mp/mrshortgame/newsletter
Mr. Short Game Stat Book ▶ https://amzn.to/4133qrv
FlightScope Discount Here ▶ https://flightscope.com/collections/all?sca_ref=11374112.EpC4NjhNLdV7
USE Code: mrshortgame
SkyTrak Here ▶ https://skytrak-5751.myshopify.com/discount/MATTFISHER
Use Code: MRSHORTGAME
Learning Program Here ▶ https://www.mrshortgame.com/
More Gear Here! ▶ https://www.amazon.com/shop/mrshortgame
Please Subscribe ▶ https://bit.ly/2FaDvFG
SOCIAL LINKS:
Spotify Podcast ▶ https://bit.ly/4imskZ5
Instagram ▶ https://www.instagram.com/mrshortgame/
Twitter ▶ https://twitter.com/MrShortGame
Website ▶ http://www.mrshortgame.com/
how was he supposedly to stand behind his ball to check the lie
He stomped he deserved all he got
Let’s address the elephant in the room!!! Rory comes right out and says he was watching it live in the clubhouse . He’s such a little crybaby Karen anymore. I strongly believe the fire was lit by little Rory 😢 crybaby . He lit the fuse to the judges. There were two officials standing just feet away from Bryson when he made his shot. Why didn’t they address then ??? All week Faldo , chamblee and some useless golf Channel and other so called critics …. Talked sh.t on Bryson all week. They clearly had it out for Bryson. Every pro golfer , minus crybaby Rory expressed their opinion on the matter. They all agreed one thing bryson is not, is a cheater . Also they all agree they really didn’t see anything he did wrong. Towards the end of Burns final round he was in the grass, he approached his ball no different than Bryson.
Can't defend it. At a tournament this weekend I asked almost all of the 96 players if he deserved the penalty. Only 2 said he was not in violation of rule 8.1 Tough they are on camera all the time but he deserves what he got.
He definately cheated. Case closed.
According to USGA Rule 8.1, you cannot step on a bush to improve your area of intended swing. You must play the ball as it lies and take the least intrusive stance possible. Bending or breaking a growing plant to clear your swing path is not allowed.
According to USGA Rule 8.1, you cannot step on a bush to improve your area of intended swing. You must play the ball as it lies and take the least intrusive stance possible. Bending or breaking a growing plant to clear your swing path is not allowed.
We saw him do it stop you're an idiot you like Bryson wonderful I'm happy for you. It's obvious he improved the swing playing obvious there's no mistaking it whether he did it on purpose or not it's not even in question. It doesn't matter. He accidentally improved his lie, two stroke penalty.
😮bubbahh whattya say we put Patrick Reed and Deeh-Shamm-Boughh together in a paring and have em watch eachother😅
Of course he cheated. ANY talk of volunteers causing a problem is rubbish. You are waffling to fudge the issue.
Whether it was intentional or unintentional is irrelevant to the rules of golf. He was deemed to have improved his lie by the way he walked around his ball. If you disagree with that rule, you probably cheat too.
Rory called it in.
The penalty should have been assessed at the time of the infraction not after the round. Also, the rules officials didn’t see it live they found out after they saw it on video which is against the rules and they should not have assessed the penalty.
No one but him know if it was intentional but that is irrelevant. Clearly, he improved his intended swing path and that is not allowed whether or not intentional. Se the penalty is deserved, end of story.
whether or not it was unintentional, I dont think it was personally and I think he argued more out of embarrassment….. the fact remains that as a pro golfer knowing the rules of golf he should have never put himself in that position in the first place, you know the cameras are on you, you know the TV viewers are looking at everything and will call in or comment online. His ball was found, I get that he needs to assess the shot but also at same time should know that walking around the ball in long grass assessing the shot is asking for trouble and that's what he got !
Was he? Yes.
He didn’t do anything that any of us would not have done. Bad judgment in my opinion
Just hit the fairway problem solved
Yes he did
The American mindset is strong with this one.
Something I learned from Law, always go back and read the section…actually read it. Whilst AI and Google summaries are great, they can generalise, which can be wrong.
The only exception here is Rule 8.1(b)(6), which allows a player to improve the conditions affecting the stroke whilst "fairly" taking a stance. However, there are two limitations: a player "is not entitled to a normal stance or swing, and must use the least intrusive course of action…". I often see players push back into a bush, which "improves the conditions affecting the stroke", and claim that it's ok because they're taking their "normal" stance…that's wrong. The guide here is "least intrusive course of action" i.e. you may not like the stance and may not be how you normally play the shot, but that's the rule. As an example, see TW's shot under a bush onto the green during the 2019 WGC-Dell Technologies Match.
A few observations regarding points the narrator makes:
1. Another misconception is intent…the commentator here states that he can walk around his ball, but not intentionally improve the conditions affecting the stroke. There is no "intent" element in the Rule…regardless of what you intended, even if the improvement occurred accidentally, the Rule is breached and, if not rectified (which you can do – Rule 8.1(c) ) before making a stroke in play, then it's a penalty i.e. it doesn't matter what De Chambeau intended to do or not do.
2. Next is the genuine query: "how do you walk around in tall grass", "what if you're looking for it". Well, there is an exception for finding your ball, which De Chambeau wasn't doing because it had already been found. He can walk wherever he likes so long as it doesn't improve the conditions affecting the stroke…pretty simple.
3. Whether the penalty is fair or just is irrelevant and subjective. If it is, the Rule and/or penalty should be changed.
4. Most sporting codes have clamped down on arguing with officials, and in many cases dissent is a breach and carries its own penalty. Yes, a player has the right to have the decision and rationale explained, but argue, no, show disgust, no, vent your frustration, no. Life's not always fair, and many a player has won a game with rediculous 1/million lucky occurrences…is that unfair to other players? It's sport, and professionals should show a level of humility. In this case, I think DeChambeau's arguing and display of emotion were childish and unprofessional. As for the threat of "taking his ball and going home", what a joke and for that he absolutely should have been DQ'd on the spot. What example does that set for young players and the community in general?
In De Chambeau's situation, the issue is simply whether the long grass behind the ball would have "affected the stroke" (it appears so) and, if so, did he improve those conditions…full stop. In my opinion, the video (which may not be accurate because of angles) shows that he did; consequently, it's a penalty.
Finally, the narrator makes the final comment, "don't hit it over there"…totally agree; otherwise, we should just have a rule that says if you don't like where your ball is, then place it on the fairway.