F1 Timing admits system errors in Monaco by Peter Windsor

F1 Timing admits system errors in Monaco by Peter Windsor



The Alpine F1 team on Thursday brilliantly launched a protest against the five-second penalty imposed upon Pierre Gasly in the Monaco GP, delivering bombshell evidence – sensationally confirmed by FOM – that the distance used in calculating the F1 Official Timing (and, hence, the pit lane speed) was indeed inaccurate. The Monaco Stewards, furthermore, on the same day revealed that, upon asking Race Control during the Monaco GP if they were aware of any issues or irregularities in the system (based on the unusual number of drivers apparently speeding), they were reassured that there were none. Peter Windsor in this video highlights the clear-thinking drive of Alpine’s Steve Nielsen and his engineering team that may well result in Pierre Gasly reclaiming P3 at Monaco (plus other potential race result changes around other drivers similarly penalised) and – obviously – much-needed revisions to the timing-loop and penalty systems.
With thanks to Jetcraft, the world’s largest buyer and seller of executive jets:

Worldwide Aircraft Sales, Acquisitions and Trading


To TrackNinja, a lap-timer and data app designed to help users improve their on-track car and driver performance through analysis and an innovative Data Garage. A lite version is free; the loaded edition is US$9.99 pcm or $99.99 yearly

TrackNinja Out Now


To OEM Exclusive, the passionate suppliers of OEM upgrades for exotic and high-performance vehicles
And to REC Watches, whose timepieces are infused with DNA and actual material from famous racing and road cars. Claim your additional 10 per cent discount by adding the codeword PETER:

Next project


Images: Craig Evans/Spacesuit Media and Pirelli
Best wishes to the Alora dog rescue shelter (Malaga, Spain): help the van transport of our friends to new locations and win a hamper along the way: https://gofund.me/6ac85a627
https://aloradogrescue.com
Visit: FXD https://fxdworkwear.com for all your purpose-build, technical workwear
Visit https://alpinestars.com for all your racing apparel
Try Oscar Razors – Australia’s highly-rated, 5-blade razors for men and women
https://oscarrazor.com.au.
Follow Peter @peterwindsor
Book a Cameo with Peter: https://cameo.com/peterwindsor
Contact us at: peterwindsoryt@gmail.com
We support the Race Against Dementia:

Home


#standwithukraine – now, more than ever
#Canada! #jimmykimmel!
Stephen Gallacher Golf Foundation
https://sgfoundation.co.uk
Nick: you’re with us always:
https://samaritans.org

View Comments (46)
  1. listening to the race live. it was absolutely obvious that there was an issue with the pitlane speed monitoring process. You don't get so many penalties being dished out.

    The FIA need to amend the rules so any pit speeding penalties are properly investigated when they occur (i.e. during the race) & if the measuring system is deemed inaccurate, the penalties are waived / scrubbed.

    Also, these cars are carrying a formidable array of sensors & data loggers – is it seriously beyond the capabilities of the FIA to cross reference their data against the GPS speed data from the teams in the pitlane zone?

    Or go back to the old school & have someone in the pit lane with a speed gun.

  2. It was obvious that with so many timing issues that the system was forked.
    Effing one isn't the pinnacle, changing the changes to the motor regulations in 6 months shows the incompetence of Ben Sulkymans regime my mate says .

  3. They can't fix last race without creating a bigger problem (George, Piastri etc) so it's gonna be what it is, can only hope future races won't have the same problem.

  4. How pathetic. Monaco is already a farce of a race every year and the most boring 70 laps in the history of racing. And they mess something up as simple as that? Ruined multiple drivers "races"

  5. Would there not be a data recording system on the cars that holds accurate and verifiable data of the absolute speed at any time during the event? Comparing that data to the official speed measuring system data would be enlightening.

  6. F1 2026: terrible "get the mushroom" racing cars, fake overtakes, tarmac breaking up, wrong timing. I am following the scene but not actively watching anymore. The sport has been destroyed by an incompetent board.

  7. Hi Peter, I love your videos. Great content. I was F1 pitlane marshall Singapore GP for 5years. I knew there had to be something wrong at Monaco. I even wonder if their speed gun was properly calibrated. The regulations also needs to be redone, in my opinion. I heard on a podcast, Rob Smedley saying that Lewis has exceeded the speed limit by 0.5 km/hour. There should be a small tolerance. Such a tiny margin makes no sense at all. What a mess.

  8. The corrupted 2021 season was for me the start of this rapid rot in F1, every season since there appears to have been more and more issues with overbearing governance, behind the scenes contrivance and manipulation of what was an almost pure sporting challenge, to becoming now this farcical serialised soap opera of so called 'entertainment'.
    Yes I still follow on the side lines but no longer watch any racing as that purity is lost!

  9. Since different drivers served their penalty in different ways, it is impossible to reallocate the results; the only solution the FIA has is to cancel the whole event, and, of course, pay a substantial fine for bringing the sport into disrepute.

  10. FIA Just announced:

    "Following a Right of Review from Alpine, the stewards of the Monaco GP have rescinded Gasly's penalties, effectively handing him back his third place finish."

  11. They have an in one in excess of 8 billion $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ can't get the basics right.
    Tarmac surface broke up causing the crashes at the corner. Speed limit sensors not calibrated correctly.
    The map showing race progress crashed during race never fixed.
    They can't even get a few supermarket floor cleaning deployed at all the corners in car of debris or excess water from rain to be cleared pronto rather than stopping the race for long periods of time while men with only hand brooms try to clear the track. It does not stop here either there are now so many thousands of rules it is almost impossible to just race.

  12. With control freak Ben in charge what do you expect !! And now teams have to pay €20K deposit for each application, so €40K , more money for Ben and his not very transparent team. Be very surprised if FIA back drivers, mean they were wrong !!

  13. Aren't we all glad Ferrari didn't do what SOME suggested and keep Charles out or swap positions to give Charles P2. Would have been a massive slap in the face to Lewis and put the team in turmoil right now

  14. Arguably FIA's biggest fuckup ever. Considering the 1989 Suzuka event was Balestre's personal doing. What if a team loses a place in the constructor's, and consequently the money, because of this event? Maybe suing FIA might not be a bad idea at all.

  15. F1 is looking as silly as NASCAR right now. NASCAR is a circus run by the clowns, F1 is a circus run by incompetent buffoons. Teams, drivers and fans deserve better.

  16. Been following F1 since the 1960’s, now I have lost intrest, don’t bother to watch the races and this sort of behaviour just reinforces the farce that F1 has become 🤮

  17. This was known before the race as it came up in free practice. The drivers were warned they had to enter pit lane a certain way to avoid getting penalized accidentally. The problem was the way the penalized drivers were entering the pit lane was otherwise legal. It was an FIA equipment problem that the drivers were told to help compensate for. Kimi remembered, Lewis forgot the first but remembered after that, and Gasly repeatedly forgot. So do you penalize drivers who fail to follow pre-race instructions?

    Yes, typically you do, but you usually give them a warning first. The stewards were not notified of the situation and just handed out penalties. It’s a communication problem within the FIA. And they’ve compounded it by rewarding Gasly. Now what do you do with the other drivers?

  18. This is completely wrong! Alpine suffered the same as everyone else… but because they did not take their penalties as others did, then one can argue that all other penalties should also be credited back with 5 seconds given back to all those who served their penalties…. The Alpine penalty should be upheld as it was equally dispensed to all teams cutting the corners!

Leave a Reply