Golf analyst Brandel Chamblee stirred fresh debate in the sport last week after asserting that The Players Championship should not only be recognized as a major, but considered the strongest major in professional golf.
Speaking during a Golf Channel segment, Chamblee argued that the tournament’s field strength and course setup surpass those of the Masters.
“The Players, to me, stands alone and above the other four major championships as not just a major, it is in my estimation, the best major.” Chamblee said. “It is the best field in golf (TPC Sawgrass). It is the deepest field in golf. And by virtue of the fact that only one person in its 50 years history has managed to successfully defend it, I would argue that it is the hardest major championship to win.”
The Players Championship has long carried the unofficial label of golf’s “fifth major,” a reflection of its stature as the PGA Tour’s flagship event. The tournament consistently features one of the deepest fields in golf, drawing nearly every top‑ranked player each year. Its purse is among the largest in the sport, and its winner receives a five‑year PGA Tour exemption, benefits that mirror those of the established majors.
The course itself, TPC Sawgrass, is central to the event’s identity. Designed by Pete Dye to challenge every aspect of a player’s game, it is known for penalizing even minor mistakes. The iconic par‑3 17th hole, with its island green, has become one of the most recognizable and pressure‑packed shots in golf.
Still, Chamblee’s comments are controversial, largely because the four majors carry a weight that cannot be replicated by field strength alone. The Masters, first played in 1934, and the Open Championship, dating back to 1860 — just two of the current majors — are steeped in tradition and global significance. Their histories shape careers and define legacies in ways The Players, founded in 1974, has yet to match.
Many in golf argue that major‑championship prestige comes from decades of history and tradition, a legacy The Players cannot fully match despite its elite field and stature.
Chamblee may face pushback from those who argue that major‑championship status is rooted in history and tradition, yet he continues to contend that The Players’ competitive demands place it on par with — or even ahead of — the established majors.
His remarks have reignited a familiar debate in golf circles: whether The Players deserves elevation or whether its unofficial status is part of what makes it unique.
More Golf: Scottie Scheffler Breaks Silence on LIV Golfers Rejoining PGA Tour