{"id":22038,"date":"2026-10-30T10:56:57","date_gmt":"2026-10-30T10:56:57","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/22038\/"},"modified":"2026-10-30T10:56:57","modified_gmt":"2026-10-30T10:56:57","slug":"real-estate-insiders-question-how-trump-fraud-judge-valued-mar-a-lago","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/22038\/","title":{"rendered":"Real estate insiders question how Trump fraud judge valued Mar-a-Lago"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>      New YorkCNN Business\u00a0\u2014\u00a0\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-d8e6d7bd430f290259b9127ddfffee7c@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            A New York judge ruled last week that former President Donald Trump inflated the value of his Mar-a-Lago estate by an eye-popping 2,300%.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-c742dbb79b48bfba116f237415878fef@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            That finding, part of shocking ruling that found Trump and his adult sons liable for fraud, was just one of multiple examples in which Judge Arthur Engoron found the Trump real estate empire to have been grossly inflated in value.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-f3606f609094d66b073c606b249cd612@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            But the Mar-a-Lago finding in particular is raising eyebrows among real estate and legal experts because of the metric Judge Engoron relied on: the county tax assessor\u2019s appraisal value.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-c5657b5a0f5eaca7fa2d830677451f8c@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            \u201cFrom 2011-2021, the Palm Beach County Assessor appraised the market value of Mar-a-Lago at between $18 million and $27.6 million,\u201d Engoron wrote in his ruling.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-0c35c936d0ee17a465ac1dcc229e09be@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            The judge noted Trump valued Mar-a-Lago at between $426.5 million and $612 million, \u201can overvaluation of at least 2,300%, compared to the assessor\u2019s appraisal.\u201d\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-edca70744ea95599d45b50fba11dee96@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            But it\u2019s widely known that the tax assessor valuation is typically, though not always, less than what a property would command on the open market.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-75c89ca8358f80809669bae16e5f9cbc@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            In other words, it\u2019s not an apples-to-apples comparison.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-7f5d99c6f230df4493b3ea546078deb7@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            \u201cAppraisal values and market values are just not the same thing. It\u2019s a well-known fact,\u201d said Eli Beracha, chair of the school of real estate at Florida International University. \u201cThat\u2019s especially true for properties that are unique. And it\u2019s very easy to argue this is a unique property.\u201d\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-0ced54209bcbb93f0d0ffa621eef9682@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Dina Goldentayer, executive director of sales at Douglas Elliman in South Florida, said in her experience in the ultra-luxury marketplace the tax assessor\u2019s valuation isn\u2019t considered when trying to value a property.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-c55727728840b61d94864b31c3b1132c@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            \u201cHe wouldn\u2019t make a very good realtor,\u201d Goldentayer said of the judge. \u201cIt\u2019s so widely known that it\u2019s not an accurate determination of market value.\u201d\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-34e7f8b13b1c0420b506c1090f5c0eb3@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Goldentayer added, \u201cIf there is a ranking as to what would have the lowest valuation, it\u2019s the tax assessor\u2019s office, followed by Zillow and then the realtor\u2019s valuation is the highest.\u201d\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-07b90ffd9ec6b1b6e2a8085fa1560fa0@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            It\u2019s not correct to assume that a tax assessment and market value are the same thing, according to Jonathan Miller, president and CEO of Miller Samuel Inc., a real estate appraisal company in New York City.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-f3d2b05d51e9fdcc8f8adbad1fedc14e@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            \u201cThey can be, in some markets they are the same thing, but in most others they are not,\u201d Miller said.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-4cb2e12a81e22bbfbf841452f605aa68@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Melissa Cintron, partner in the insurance defense and corporate and real estate practice groups at Harrington Ocko &amp; Monk, said it\u2019s \u201cnot contestable\u201d that Mar-a-Lago is worth more than $28 million based on improvements and a market analysis.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-06ef756af7f04e23fa9a114c6420bdbe@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Of course, just because the tax assessment value used by the judge may have lowballed the value of Mar-a-Lago, doesn\u2019t necessarily mean Trump used a fair valuation for Mar-a-Lago. That point is up for debate.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-55370ce1e00170f244bdef8439ee517a@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            \u201cIt is certainly not clear what the value is,\u201d said Miller. \u201cThe test is what the market would suss out for the property. The challenge is that isn\u2019t a single-family house.\u201d\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-7d2fe51b20ba65db772ad632e191ff8a@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            The judge, in his ruling, noted that Trump agreed to use Mar-a-Lago as a social club and that there are restrictions limiting the property\u2019s potential use as a single-family residence.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-d473377b27c9b585ea385626cdd299b0@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Typically, realtors, buyers and sellers would try to determine an estimated valuation on a property by comparing it to similar ones that have been recently sold in the same area. But that may not be possible when dealing with a unique property, especially one owned by a famous person and that functions as a private club.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-b653c4dcf781ce6d608d2534bc3d0537@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            \u201cMar-a-Lago is such a trophy asset. It\u2019s in a completely different league of its own,\u201d said Goldentayer, the South Florida realtor.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-f2aa48c9b004503d976ec834599862c6@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Goldentayer said to come up with a value on Mar-a-Lago, she would hire three independent appraisers and take a blended average of their valuations. She would not use the tax appraiser\u2019s valuation.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-afd6533b7bdc74b5b1ceda7d8da10ba0@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Trump and his attorneys have strongly criticized last week\u2019s ruling. Trump attorney Christopher Kise called the ruling \u201ccompletely disconnected from the facts and governing law.\u201d\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-3bcd975b231439d3bbab8a3de321de45@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Trump accused Engoron of \u201cdoing the bidding\u201d of New York Attorney General Letitia James.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-4d5af5b781d534174b8bb2f47a042645@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            However, the ruling was not based solely on Mar-a-Lago. The NY judge found multiple instances of Trump and his adult sons having inflated the value of properties.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-e50d9eb642e0d6b2712e74f90459b72c@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            For instance, Engoron found that Trump inflated the value of properties at 40 Wall Street and the Seven Springs Estate in Westchester County, NY as well as a golf course in Aberdeen, Scotland.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-3216527e5f0f13971882a135a059e454@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Notably, Engoron found Trump inflated the size of his triplex apartment at Trump Tower by three times, causing an overvaluation of between $114 million and $207 million.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-15a5fec8fe68a2b46b0685b2e97c7578@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            \u201cA discrepancy of this order of magnitude, by a real estate developer sizing up his own living space of decades, can only be considered fraud,\u201d Engoron wrote.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-2bf3c60455a18caa7305390ec4808f86@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            Cintron, the Harrington Ocko &amp; Monk partner, doesn\u2019t think the Mar-a-Lago valuation controversy moves the needle on the question of whether Trump committed fraud.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-92b98613700a8577c8c554649b4692de@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            \u201cThere is enough of a pattern of this practice that he\u2019s engaged with in respect to his properties to support Judge Engoron\u2019s conclusions that there was an intent to defraud,\u201d Cintron said.\n    <\/p>\n<p class=\"paragraph-elevate inline-placeholder vossi-paragraph_elevate\" data-uri=\"cms.cnn.com\/_components\/paragraph\/instances\/paragraph-23c576c42a125cfba625968f28b4bcaa@published\" data-editable=\"text\" data-component-name=\"paragraph\" data-article-gutter=\"true\">\n            CNN\u2019s Anna Bahney contributed to this report.\n    <\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"New YorkCNN Business\u00a0\u2014\u00a0 A New York judge ruled last week that former President Donald Trump inflated the value&hellip;","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":22039,"comment_status":"","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"csco_display_header_overlay":false,"csco_singular_sidebar":"","csco_page_header_type":"","csco_page_load_nextpost":"","csco_post_video_location":[],"csco_post_video_location_hash":"","csco_post_video_url":"","csco_post_video_bg_start_time":0,"csco_post_video_bg_end_time":0,"csco_post_video_bg_volume":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[7],"tags":[11187,568,11188,11190,4754,11191,4757,217,11189,4758,11192,11193,11194,11195,11196,11197,11198,4761,11199,11200,4764,11201,4767,11202,3058,11203,11204,959,310,11205,4769,11206,11207,625,11208,11209,11210],"class_list":["post-22038","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","category-new-york","tag-arthur-engoron","tag-business","tag-business-and-industry-sectors","tag-destinations-and-attractions","tag-domestic-alerts","tag-domestic-business","tag-domestic-us-politics","tag-donald-trump","tag-economy-and-trade","tag-government-and-public-administration","tag-government-bodies-and-offices","tag-government-departments-and-authorities","tag-iab-business-and-finance","tag-iab-economy","tag-iab-financial-regulation","tag-iab-industries","tag-iab-law","tag-iab-politics","tag-iab-real-estate","tag-iab-real-estate-industry","tag-international-alerts","tag-international-business","tag-international-us-politics","tag-law-and-legal-system","tag-mar-a-lago","tag-misc-people","tag-misc-places","tag-new-york","tag-new-york-golf","tag-points-of-interest","tag-political-figures-us","tag-public-finance","tag-public-finance-agencies-and-treasuries","tag-real-estate","tag-tax-assessors","tag-tax-law","tag-taxes-and-taxation","cs-entry","cs-video-wrap"],"share_on_mastodon":{"url":"","error":""},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/22038","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=22038"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/22038\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/22039"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=22038"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=22038"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.fogolf.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=22038"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}