Oct. 27, 2026, 9:36 a.m. ET
A plan to convert a citrus grove into a private golf club in East Naples has been stalled by a procedural error.Collier County missed a 180-day state deadline to approve a required growth plan amendment by more than a year.FloridaCommerce has deemed the amendment “withdrawn,” returning it to the county without implementation.Opponents of the development, including environmental groups and neighbors, may have another chance to fight the project.
Opponents could get another chance to fight the conversion of a long-time citrus grove into an exclusive, private golf club in East Naples.
According to a letter from FloridaCommerce, Collier County missed the state’s deadline to submit its final approval of a required growth plan amendment by more than a year.
After an hours-long hearing on Sept. 22, county commissioners unanimously approved the amendment and rezoning, which faced strong opposition from neighbors who hoped to somehow preserve the 169-acre South Naples Citrus Grove.
The state received the county’s adopted amendment on Oct. 2.
FloridaCommerce deemed it “withdrawn” under state law a few days later because the county took far too long to approve the amendment after the state’s initial review last year.
USA TODAY Shopping: Shop sales in tech, home, fashion, beauty & more curated by our editors.
As a result of the delay, the state returned the amendment to the county without action — or implementation.

County commissioners voted to transmit the original amendment to the state for review on May 27, 2025. The state sent its review back to the county a little over a month later, on July 2.
After the county received the state’s comments, it had 180 days to hold the second and final hearing on the amendment and adopt it, unless it had an approved extension. No such extension was ever requested.
The county commission did hold a second hearing on the amendment on Jan. 13, 2026, but even that would not have met the state’s deadline. At that hearing, the board delayed action, sending the grove owners and developers back to the drawing board.
The developers wanted to replace the grove with up to 423 homes (including affordable housing). County commissioners balked at the request but did not deny it, instead asking them to either return with a much less intensive proposal that didn’t involve housing — or find a way to preserve and protect the property.
The effort ended with a revised request for a members-only golf club, which finally won over the county commission last month.

Mike Bosi, the county’s director of planning and zoning, said the county attorney’s office is coordinating with FloridaCommerce on a “path forward.
“As of now, we do not have certainty on the path forward,” he said.
However, he said that he expected to know more by the end of this week, at which time the county will be able to “relay what hearings will be required.”
Late last week, Rich Yovanovich, the land-use attorney representing the golf club’s developers, said he had just returned from an international trip, and he didn’t yet have his arms around the situation. He, too, expected to know more about the next steps this week.

After learning of the letter from FloridaCommerce, Matthew Schwartz, executive director of the South Florida Wildlands Association, posted about it on his group’s Facebook page last week. His is one of several environmental groups that fought the development plans.
He commented that it appeared the revised amendment for the golf club was “effectively ‘dead on arrival’ because of a major blunder involving the state’s review timeline.
“The math is simple: 447 days had passed between the state’s July 2, 2025, review and the county’s September 22, 2026, approval vote — obliterating the 180-day legal limit,” he said.
In his view, Schwartz said the county could have avoided the outcome by starting a new amendment process for the golf course, with “a fresh state review and a new timeline for adoption.”
“Instead, the county apparently continued using the earlier amendment process, even though its 180-day deadline had long since expired. That procedural mistake — possibly an intentional shortcut — appears to have led directly to the state’s determination that the amendment has now been withdrawn,” Schwartz said.
He added: “Again, to the best of our knowledge, if the developer and county still want to move forward withthe golf course, they will have to initiate a new amendment approval process. That would likely mean issuing new public notices, holding new public hearings and votes, and transmitting a new proposed amendment to Tallahassee.”
The amendment faced opposition from environmentalists and neighbors
The development of the property sparked environmental concerns because it borders the Picayune Strand State Forest and other protected preserves and sits within the protected Florida Wildlife Corridor, where panthers and other endangered and threatened animals roam.
Neighbors fought the project, concerned about the impact on their rural way of life and on wildlife. Two petitions aimed at stopping development garnered thousands of signatures.
Although the commission unanimously approved the rezoning and amendment, the vote included conditions and concessions, such as eliminating the proposed cottages for short stays by members and their guests.
The grove property was zoned agricultural, and it had a protected status in the Rural Fringe Mixed-Use District. It was a “sending area” that limited development without a growth plan amendment.
The land sits about 1.4 miles east of Collier Boulevard, off a rural two-lane road.
The property — at 341 Sabal Palm Road — has been home to the South Naples Citrus Grove for decades. Known for its Old Florida charm, the roadside farmer’s market has been family-owned and operated since 1978, selling fresh citrus fruits and freshly squeezed citrus juices, and other produce and treats, including orange-swirled soft-serve ice cream, in season.
The grove, however, has been decimated by citrus greening, an incurable tree-killing disease, making it an unviable commercial enterprise.
The market plans to reopen this season in mid-to-late November, but this season could be its last.
Laura Layden is a senior business and government reporter. Reach her by email at laura.layden@naplesnews.com.Â
Please support local community journalism and stay informed about Southwest Florida news by subscribing to The News-Press and Naples Daily News; download the free News-Press or Naples Daily News app, and sign up for daily briefing email newsletter, food & dining and growth & development newsletters here and here.Â
Do you have an opinion about this topic? Send us a letter to the editor or guest column at mailbag@news-press.com or letters@naplesnews.com.
