San Diego’s public golf courses are raking in millions in profits — and helping fund some major upgrades – San Diego Union-Tribune

San Diego’s public golf courses are raking in millions in profits — and helping fund some major upgrades – San Diego Union-Tribune

San Diego’s three municipal golf courses generated $14 million in profits during the last fiscal year, thanks to a record 420,000 rounds played — but city officials still plan to raise green fees Jan. 1 to help pay for course upgrades.

City officials also plan to hire a consultant next year to create the Golf Division’s first new business plan since 2012. The plan will focus on how best to cope with the surge in demand that began early in the COVID-19 pandemic.

The new business plan will also analyze how Torrey Pines could land another U.S. Open, which has become more challenging now that the organization that runs the tournament has shifted how it selects courses.

City officials said the three courses — Torrey, Mission Bay and Balboa — are becoming steadily more important, especially as the aging of San Diego’s population increases how many retired people are searching for outdoor recreation.

Golfers played a record 419,843 rounds at the courses during the fiscal year that ended July 1, which was 68,000 rounds above the target set by city officials.

The best results came at Balboa’s nine-hole course, where 83,683 rounds were played but only 60,000 had been projected, and at the south course at Torrey, with 81,385 rounds versus 64,000 projected.

Revenue rose from $32.9 million in fiscal 2022 to $36.9 million in fiscal 2023 to $39.4 million in fiscal 2024 — but profits have risen by much smaller margins, because expenses have risen 22% in just three years.

City officials said the main drivers of rising expenses have been wages for the division’s 120 workers, utilities and the costs of equipment and other goods. Overall expenses rose from $20.7 million in fiscal 2022 to $25.3 million in fiscal 2024.

Golfers walk to the fairway at Balboa Park Golf Course on Thursday, Dec. 5, 2024 in San Diego. (Meg McLaughlin / The San Diego Union-Tribune)Golfers walk to the fairway at Balboa Park Golf Course on Thursday, Dec. 5, 2024 in San Diego. (Meg McLaughlin / The San Diego Union-Tribune)

Profits generated by the courses were $12.2 million in fiscal 2022, $14 million in fiscal 2023 and $14.1 million in fiscal 2024. Those profits have helped the golf division amass $39.4 million in reserves.

City officials give much of the credit to Balboa and Mission Bay, which have been breaking even financially in recent years, after many years of being subsidized by Torrey.

Councilmember Jennifer Campbell said it’s refreshing the division doesn’t need subsidies. “I can’t tell you how much I love a division that pays for itself,” she said last month during a presentation to the council’s Environment Committee.

Despite the strong financial performance, the city is raising green fees — the price golfers pay per round — at every course by 3% for city residents and 5% for non-residents.

City officials said the additional revenue the higher fees will generate is needed to cover rising expenses and pay for a wide variety of badly needed capital improvement projects.

Those projects include a new clubhouse and maintenance building at Torrey Pines, a new food service building at Mission Bay and a new practice area at Balboa for chipping and putting.

The new clubhouse at Torrey, which will cost an estimated $60 million, will include a new golf shop, a barn for 150 golf carts and office space for Golf Division staff.

At Balboa, the nine-hole course will be realigned to make way for the practice area. The road through the course will also be shifted to create a safer path for pedestrians and bicyclists.

And at Mission Bay, the 2,175-square-foot food and beverage building is a continuation of major renovations that began two years ago and that saw new lighting, a new irrigation system and a new pro shop recently completed. The total cost for all the Mission Bay upgrades is $15 million.

Golfers putt at Balboa Park Golf Course on Thursday, Dec. 5, 2024 in San Diego. (Meg McLaughlin / The San Diego Union-Tribune)Golfers putt at Balboa Park Golf Course on Thursday, Dec. 5, 2024 in San Diego. (Meg McLaughlin / The San Diego Union-Tribune)

City officials say the upgrades often partly pay for themselves, citing an irrigation system at Mission Bay that has reduced water bills there. And they say golfers are less likely to return to a course that’s in mediocre condition.

With the rate hikes, weekend fees at the nine-hole course at Balboa will rise from $22.50 to $23 for residents and from $29 to $31 for non-residents.

Rates for Balboa’s 18-hole course will rise from $46 to $48 for residents and from $64.50 to $68 for non-residents.

At Mission Bay, they’ll rise from $35 to $36 for residents and from $46 to $49 for non-residents.

And at Torrey South, weekend rates will rise from $85 to $88 for residents and from $292 to $306 for non-residents. At Torrey North, they’ll rise from $64 to $66 for residents and from $185 to $194 for non-residents.

Rates are much higher at Torrey because it hosts professional events and has iconic ocean views.

City officials said they expect the new business plan to be completed next year.

“Obviously the old plan was a success, but we really want to modernize it for the years to come,” said John Howard, the city’s deputy director for golf operations.

A golfer walks along the cart path at Balboa Park Golf Course on Thursday, Dec. 5, 2024 in San Diego. (Meg McLaughlin / The San Diego Union-Tribune)A golfer walks along the cart path at Balboa Park Golf Course on Thursday, Dec. 5, 2024 in San Diego. (Meg McLaughlin / The San Diego Union-Tribune)

One big change since the last plan was created in 2012 is a surge in golfing that began earlier in the pandemic when people were searching for new outdoor activities.

By last year, more than 123 million Americans were playing golf, up 13% since 2019, according to the National Golf Foundation. Its 2023 report found that rounds played were up more than 53% nationwide in less than a decade.

The business plan will likely address marketing and payment strategies. The city recently added a San Diego City Golf smartphone app that officials say has 29,000 active users, and it now sells resident identification cards online.

The rate increases will include a more generous deal for junior golfers under 18. They can still play unlimited rounds for $10.50 per month, but they will also be able to buy an annual pass for $75.

City officials said they plan to pursue another U.S. Open at Torrey, which hosted the prestigious event — one of golf’s four major championships — in 2008 and 2021.

But the organization that runs the event, the U.S. Golf Association, has adopted a new strategy in recent years of awarding the event more frequently to a handful of “anchor” courses and spreading it around less.

Six courses have been awarded multiple U.S. Opens in coming years, and sites have already been selected for all future U.S. Opens through 2042. Torrey isn’t among them.

Justin Thomas hits from the fairway on the fourth hole during the third round of The Farmers Insurance Open on the South Course at Torrey Pines Golf Course on January 28, 2022 in La Jolla, California. (Photo by Donald Miralle/Getty Images)

Those six courses are Pebble Beach in Northern California, Oakmont and Merion in Pennsylvania, Pinehurst in North Carolina, Oakland Hills in Michigan and Shinnecock Hills in New York.

Torrey continues to get national TV exposure by hosting a regular tour event each January, the Farmer’s Insurance Open. But a major championship brings worldwide attention.

City officials could try to land the other major championship Torrey is eligible to host, the PGA Championship, which is held each May.

Councilmember Campbell said it’s particularly important for the city’s municipal courses to be well-maintained with so many more older and retired people in San Diego, pointing out that about a quarter of residents are 55 or older.

In addition to the three golf courses run by the city, San Diego owns seven other courses that are run by private operators.

They are Carlton Oaks in Santee, the Vineyard on the city’s border with Escondido and five in San Diego: Fairbanks Ranch Country Club, Mission Trails, Presidio Hills, Tecolote Canyon and Pro Kids Golf Academy in Colina del Sol.