Golfweek 2026: 17 NY golf courses rank among top 100 classic courses

Golfweek 2026: 17 NY golf courses rank among top 100 classic courses

Aug. 4, 2026, 3:28 a.m. ET

Golfweek has released its 2026 ranking of the nation’s best classic golf courses, and more than a dozen New York courses made the list.

The ranking evaluates the top 200 U.S. golf courses that opened before 1960, based on ratings from Golfweek’s panel of course evaluators. Earlier this month, Golfweek similarly ranked the nation’s best modern golf courses and four New York golf courses were among the best, according to the rankings.

Why does Golfweek split rankings between modern and classic? Simple – they are two very different eras.

In considering both categories, each course must receive at least 25 ratings from panel members to be eligible, according to Golfweek. Only rounds played within the past 10 years are considered, helping ensure courses continue to meet the publication’s standards over time.

Here’s which New York classic golf courses are some of the best in the country.

Prime Day deals are live: Shop our editors’ top picks across tech, home, outdoors and more.Classic New York courses in Golfweek’s top 100

To be considered a classic course by Golfweek, the course has to have opened before 1960 in the U.S.

“The Classic style of architecture was basically natural with intimate routings that enabled holes to cling to native landforms,” according to Golfweek. “Greens were built from native soil that was pushed up and shaped, giving Classic designers enormous freedom to build oddly shaped putting surfaces with more contour than typically seen in the Modern era, when green speeds became much greater.”

Here’s more on the 17 classic golf courses in New York within Golfweek’s top 100.

National Golf Links of AmericaPrivate Golf Course in NY2026 ranking: No. 4Average rating: 9.25Where the course is located: 149 Sebonac Inlet Road, SouthamptonWho designed the course: Charles Blair MacdonaldWhen the course opened: 1911Type of course: PrivateShinnecock Hills Golf ClubShinnecock Hills in New York.2026 ranking: No. 5Average rating: 9.21Where the course is located: 200 Tuckahoe Road in SouthamptonWho designed the course: William S. Flynn, Howard C. ToomeyWhen the course opened: 1931Type of course: PrivateFishers Island Club2026 ranking: No. 9Average rating: 8.78Where the course is located: 20449 East Main Road, Fishers IslandWho designed the course: Seth RaynorWhen the course opened: 1926Type of course: PrivateWinged Foot Golf Club (West)2026 ranking: No. 16Average rating: 8.40Where the course is located: 851 Fenimore Road, MamaroneckWho designed the course: A.W. TillinghastWhen the course opened: 1923Type of course: PrivateMaidstone Club2026 ranking: No. 24Average rating: 8.10Where the course is located: 50 Old Beach Lane, East HamptonWho designed the course: William H. Tucker, Willie Park Jr.When the course opened: 1899Type of course: PrivateBethpage State Park Golf Course (Black)Bethpage Black in New York (Peter Casey-USA TODAY Sports)2026 ranking: Tied for No. 27Average rating: 7.99Where the course is located: 99 Quaker Meeting House Road, FarmingdaleWho designed the course: A.W. TillinghastWhen the course opened: 1935Type of course: Daily fee/municipalGarden City Golf Club2026 ranking: No. 29Average rating: 7.96Where the course is located: 315 Stewart Ave., Garden CityWho designed the course: Devereaux Emmet, Walter J. TravisWhen the course opened: 1901Type of course: PrivateOak Hill Country Club (East)An aerial view of Oak Hill Country Club in Rochester, New York. (Photo: Gabe Gudgel/Golfweek)2026 ranking: Tied for No. 30Average rating: 7.93Where the course is located: 145 Kilbourn Road, PittsfordWho designed the course: Donald Ross, Andrew GreenWhen the course opened: 1926Type of course: PrivateSleepy Hollow Country Club2026 ranking: Tied for No. 32Average rating: 7.91Where the course is located: 777 Albany Post Road, Briarcliff ManorWho designed the course: Charles Blair Macdonald, Seth RaynorWhen the course opened: 1913Type of course: PrivateWinged Foot Golf Club (East)2026 ranking: No. 37Average rating: 7.87Where the course is located: 851 Fenimore Road, MamaroneckWho designed the course: A.W. TillinghastWhen the course opened: 1923Type of course: PrivatePiping Rock Club2026 ranking: No. 39Average rating: 7.83Where the course is located: 150 Piping Rock Road, Locust ValleyWho designed the course: Charles Blair Macdonald, Seth RaynorWhen the course opened: 1913Type of course: PrivateQuaker Ridge Golf Club2026 ranking: No. 42Average rating: 7.78Where the course is located: 146 Griffen Ave., ScarsdaleWho designed the course: A.W. TillinghastWhen the course opened: 1926Type of course: PrivateThe Creek2026 ranking: Tied for No. 53Average rating: 7.64Where the course is located: 1 Horse Hollow Road, Locust ValleyWho designed the course: Charles Blair Macdonald, Seth RaynorWhen the course opened: 1925Type of course: PrivateGlens Falls Country Club2026 ranking: No. 72Average rating: 7.35Where the course is located: 211 Round Pond Road, QueensburyWho designed the course: Donald RossWhen the course opened: 1912Type of course: PrivateSt. George’s Golf and Country Club2026 ranking: Tied for No. 73Average rating: 7.34Where the course is located: 134 Lower Sheep Pasture Road, SetauketWho designed the course: Devereaux EmmetWhen the course opened: 1917Type of course: PrivateCountry Club of Buffalo2026 ranking: 76Average rating: 7.33Where the course is located: 250 Youngs Road, WilliamsvilleWho designed the course: Donald RossWhen the course opened: 1926Type of course: PrivateFenway Golf Club2026 ranking: Tied for No. 80Average rating: 7.30Where the course is located: 384 Old Mamaroneck Road, ScarsdaleWho designed the course: A.W. TillinghastWhen the course opened: 1924Type of course: PrivateOther NY golf courses listed among the best classic coursesDay two of stroke play at the U.S. Women's Amateur Golf Championship at the Westchester Country Club Aug. 3, 2021.

The following NY golf courses ranked on the second half of the list:

Wykagyl Country Club (No. 111) New Rochelle, Westchester CountyWestchester Country Club (No. 113) Rye, Westchester CountyWhippoorwill Club (Tied for No. 115) Armonk, Westchester CountyMeadow Brook Club (No. 119) Jericho, Nassau CountyDeepdale Golf Club (Tied for No. 124) Manhasset, Nassau CountyWesthampton Country Club (Tied for No. 129) Westhampton Beach, Suffolk CountySouthampton Golf Club (Tied for No. 133) Southampton, Suffolk CountyMonroe Golf Club (Tied for No. 141) Pittsford, Monroe CountyCentury Country Club (Tied for No. 152) Purchase, Westchester CountyOak Hill Country Club – west course (No. 156) Pittsford, Monroe CountySands Point Golf Club (No. 159) Sands Point, Nassau CountyMetropolis (Tied for No. 160) White Plains, Westchester CountyCountry Club of Troy (Tied for No. 170) Troy, Rensselaer CountyLeatherstocking Golf Course (No. 176) Cooperstown, Otsego CountyRockaway Hunting Club (Tied for No. 185) Cedarhurst, Nassau CountyEngineers Country Club (Tied for No. 187) Roslyn Harbor, Nassau CountySiwanoy (Tied for No. 199) Bronxville, Westchester County

Contributing: USA Today Network