J.J. Spaun has admitted that he was annoyed with himself in the weeks after The Players Championship in 2025 after almost accepting defeat before he had even squared off with Rory McIlroy.
Spaun is widely considered one of the best players in the world right now. He is, of course, a major champion, having won the US Open at Oakmont last year.
However, heading into the start of the 2025 season, the Californian was far from a household name. He had not won on the PGA Tour since his maiden victory in 2022. Spaun also did not play in a single major in 2024.
But after three rounds of The Players Championship in 2025, Spaun led by one shot. Crucially, he was four shots ahead of Rory McIlroy at TPC Sawgrass.
J.J. Spaun reveals the mistake he made ahead of the playoff with Rory McIlroy at The Players Championship
Spaun came agonisingly close to winning the PGA Tour‘s flagship event on the 72nd hole, with his birdie putt left in the jaws of the hole.
Due to poor weather earlier in the day, Spaun and McIlroy had to return on Monday for the playoff. By the time they walked off the 17th tee – the second of three holes they were set to play – it was clear that the Northern Irishman would secure his second title at Sawgrass.
Spaun found the water and ended up making a triple bogey. It appeared that the occasion may have got to him, with McIlroy no stranger to the biggest stages.
What is your best ever score for 18 holes?
No, pitch and putt does not count!

And speaking on the We Need a Fourth Podcast about the week, Spaun admitted that he was annoyed with the attitude he took into the showdown with McIlroy.
“Kind of looking back, I didn’t want to admit this, but I almost felt way too content with getting myself in a playoff. I was like, ‘oh, I can’t finish worse than second tomorrow’. Let’s be real, I’m going up against Rory McIlroy in a three-hole aggregate playoff. I kind of defeated myself, which I kicked myself for weeks after,” he said.
“I almost was like dude, second’s great, this is the biggest purse, the most money you’ve ever made, this already got you to the top-30 in the world, you’re in The Masters the following month. This is such a good consolation if you don’t win. I was almost accepting a defeat already before even playing this thing, because I felt like I achieved so much by being first loser, more than I ever had in my career. Mentally, I wish I was a little more cutthroat. It felt weird that I had to go into a whole other day just to play three holes.”
J.J. Spaun explains how difficult it was to prepare for the playoff at TPC Sawgrass
Many will remember the baffled look on Spaun’s face after he hit the tee shot onto the iconic 17th hole. With McIlroy already safely aboard the green, it looked to be the final nail in the coffin.
The weather played a big part in putting doubt into Spaun’s mind. He explained just how difficult it was to prepare for the challenge he faced against McIlroy on that Monday morning.
“The weird thing was the huge storm that came in Sunday that made us come back the next day brought in a north wind. So it was blowing like 40 miles an hour, and it was like 52 degrees at the course on Monday morning. And we hadn’t played in a north wind all week, and it was blowing 40, and it was freezing, so it was going to be tough,” he said.
“Of course, the way they do the tiebreak to start the playoff is first man in gets the tee. So of course, here comes McIlroy, par five, number 16, he just ships this drive like 430 yards right in my face. I’m like, alright, now I’ve got to go hit after that. What the hell? He just f—— demolished this thing. I’m like s—. It’s a par five, he hit pitching wedge in.
“Now I’m one down, but with the conditions and those two holes to play, he could still lose and I could still win. He goes first, hits the green, hits a great shot. He did exactly what he needed to, just hit the green. And I’m standing over it, I’m in between clubs. Where we were warming up on the range in the same wind direction that we’re on this tee shot on 17, the par three with the water, the island green, and I’m literally hitting my eight iron on the range in the warm up before we go to the playoff like 128 yards, and the pin is 130 yards, with an eight iron, because the ball’s just getting up and it’s getting hammered. I had my Trackman out there, and it’s tracking the actual distance. Nine is not even going to get off the tee box because it’s so into the wind. It’s not even going to make it over the water. And so I hit a smooth little eight, got it up in the air how I wanted to, I didn’t flight it down at all.
“Rory hit nine, but he really flighted it, and he’s stronger. He hits it way further than me, so it was a nice, controlled nine to the back centre part of the green. I executed the shot exactly how I wanted to, and it was going just left of the pin, exactly where I wanted over that left part of the bunker. To me, it looked like it was going to be just right, and then all of a sudden, it disappeared. We didn’t hear any groans, any cheering, and I had no idea where it went. I had to ask the chief referee, Gary, where is that? I thought it was maybe in the front bunker, plugged down there or something. He’s like it’s water, long. And I’m like what?”
It was a real shame because Spaun had come so close to winning the event on Sunday evening anyway. Many players would have struggled to come back from the manner in which he lost that playoff.
However, Spaun refused to accept the limit he had put on himself. As it turns out, he had been comfortable with the stakes he was playing for. He just did not adapt to the conditions as well as McIlroy did.
That must have helped him out when he put himself in the mix to win the US Open a few months later. He bounced back from an awful start on Sunday to go on and win at Oakmont.
It was fitting that it was a stunning tee shot on 17th and a putt he did hole on 18 that helped him banish any painful memories from Sawgrass.