Fans React to U.S. Presidents Cup Squad Selection

Fans React to U.S. Presidents Cup Squad Selection

The 2026 Presidents Cup selections have sparked plenty of debate among golf fans. Team USA captain Brandt Snedeker chose six players to join the automatic qualifiers, with Patrick Cantlay, Justin Thomas and Jackson Koivun among the most discussed names. The final squad now has a mix of proven Presidents Cup players, major champions and young stars.

Snedeker used a mix of experience and current form for his six captain’s picks for the 2026 Presidents Cup. He chose Cantlay, Xander Schauffele and Thomas for their team-event experience and ability to handle pressure. Snedeker also backed Chris Gotterup, Jacob Bridgeman and 21-year-old Koivun after strong seasons.

Gotterup had three PGA Tour wins, while Bridgeman won the Genesis Invitational. Koivun made the boldest case after he won the 3M Open in just his third start as a pro. Ryan Gerard was among the players who missed out despite his strong season and recent results. The U.S. team will now turn its focus to Medinah Country Club, where it will face the International team from September 24-27.

Fans online had mixed reactions to the final U.S. Presidents Cup picks. While some supported the squad, others questioned a few of Snedeker’s decisions, especially the choices of Cantlay and Koivun.

Here’s a look at some of the reactions:

“Anybody but Cantlay!!! I won’t be watching when he is playing. I don’t understand how he got on the team. He hasn’t done much all season. Same thing with Justin Thomas,” one fan wrote.

“Embarrassing,” another user noted.

Image of Jackson Koivun earned a surprise Team USA pick at just 21.Jackson Koivun earned a surprise Team USA pick at just 21. (Source: AP)

“Call me stupid, but I think a body of work is more important than 1 good week. Ryan Gerard deserves a spot more than Jackson Koivun. Koivun probably will be a super star but, not this year…” this user pointed out.

“Picking Koivun is a slap in the face of longstanding players,” another fan stated.

Image of Brandt Snedeker finalized his U.S. roster with six captain's picks.Brandt Snedeker finalized his U.S. roster with six captain’s picks. (Source: AP)

“The Koivun pick is probably a little premature in his career. That’s the only one that feels really out there to me. Love the kid, but Gerard has earned it and is playing well right now,” one user explained.

Presidents Cup 2026 Final U.S. Roster

Captain’s Picks

Chris Gotterup

Xander Schauffele

Justin Thomas

Patrick Cantlay

Jacob Bridgeman

Jackson Koivun

Image of Chris Gotterup will make his Presidents Cup debut at Medinah Country Club.Chris Gotterup will make his Presidents Cup debut at Medinah Country Club. (Source: AP)

Automatic Qualifiers

Scottie Scheffler

Cameron Young

Wyndham Clark

Sam Burns

Russell Henley

Collin Morikawa

Presidents Cup 2026 Final International Roster

Captain’s Picks

Corey Conners

Nico Echavarria

Nick Taylor

Sungjae Im

Ryo Hisatsune

Christiaan Bezuidenhout

Image of Jackson Koivun secured his Presidents Cup spot after a rapid rise on Tour.Jackson Koivun secured his Presidents Cup spot after a rapid rise on Tour. (Source: AP)

Automatic Qualifiers

Si Woo Kim

Ryan Fox

Hideki Matsuyama

Min Woo Lee

Tom Kim

Adam Scott

Read Next

Follow The Women’s Golf Journal:

Got a tip? Send it to Women’s Golf Journal here.

Add Women’s Golf Journal on Google

Ananya Giri is a writer at Women’s Golf Journal.