Robert MacIntyre tees off on the third hole during the first round of the Tour Championship, the final event of the PGA Tour playoffs, on Aug. 27. AP-Yonhap
Robert MacIntyre of Scotland finished tied for 10th at the BMW PGA Championship, a flagship DP World Tour event that ended on the 20th at Wentworth Club in England. He closed with a birdie-birdie-eagle finish over his final three holes.
But MacIntyre voiced frustration after the round, over a rules decision on the par-4 11th hole. He had driven the ball into the fairway on that hole. When he reached his second shot, however, he found the ball sitting inside a pitch mark left by another player’s ball.
MacIntyre had expected free relief. The scope of relief for an embedded ball was broadened this year. Under Rule 16.3, relief for an embedded ball applies only when the ball comes to rest in a pitch mark made by the player’s own previous stroke. But a local rule was added allowing free relief when a player’s ball comes to rest in an unrepaired pitch mark made by another player (Model Local Rule F-2.3).
The referee who came to the scene, however, ruled that it was not a free relief situation. Why?
Under Model Local Rule F-2.3, one of the conditions for free relief is that the ball lies in an “unrepaired” pitch mark made by another player. A pitch mark is treated as repaired if it has been pressed down or restored in any way by anyone, whether deliberately or accidentally, and regardless of the quality or completeness of the repair.
For example, the pitch mark counts as repaired if it has been pressed down with a club or a foot, if someone has fixed it using a tee or another tool, or if a mower has passed over it.
The referee said at the time that he had judged the pitch mark in which MacIntyre’s ball lay to be partially restored. Relief was therefore denied.
MacIntyre failed to reach the green with his second shot and made bogey on the hole. “My ball was in a pitch mark, but I didn’t get relief because it looked like someone had stepped on it or a cart had driven over it,” he said. “This rule is absolutely ridiculous.”

Complicated and confusing golf rules often spark arguments among playing partners. Knowing the rules makes golf more enjoyable — and sometimes they can even help you shave strokes off your score. Subscribe, and one day you too will be a rules expert. Questions are welcome at sygolf@sedaily.com.