"There's only one Port player on the list you clown! What are you talking about? "……."Well two Port players actually." Classic Kane Cornes earning all the love he gets!
what is the measure of determining whether player x is underrated? amount of times mentioned on TV, media articles, supercoach, state of club, break out season predicted? Most i/state clubs will generally have a lot of under the radar types who get the job done and do it well.
It's not the 2 out 10 on the list as so much the problem, I can always fit Peter Matera, Jeremy McGovern and Josh Kennedy etc in my all time best 22. Everybody will always see 10-15% from their club of support or employment on the list with every ranking as fairly justified, it's the certainty of it which makes it pointless, because we know there's 1-2 players Kane didn't bother to truely look for and that's really the definition of finding underrated.
McCluggage – one of the cleanest midfielders in the comp, equally damaging inside and outside, has played a massive role in Brisbane's rise from wooden-spooners in his first season to Premiers. Somehow never gets the plaudits he deserves (although to be fair, it's a stacked midfield at Brisbane and Neale takes most of the spotlight deservedly so)
No Gerrard, the Swans are not thinking of playing McDonald back, you are. You have been on this bee in your bonnet ever since he kicked his first goal. He will play bloody forward Gerrard. McCartin might at some stages too. The idea is to ease players like Snell, Andrews and Hamling into the backs. With Rampe set to retire, and not playing tall anymore, these players need to step up and Logan is not in the mix. He sits in the forward line as the third tall, the Gunston role and he kicked 37 last season and will kick 50 next. But wait, there's more. I think Joel Amartey is the smokie here. I think he is the player capable of kicking the next 100. If he learns to be more consistent, his best is amazing, his worst is horrible, he will be a star.
I'd think about a Hardwick, Scrimshaw but I like the list overall. MacDonald is highly underrated, Mackenzie I think will actually be better in long run than Connor but rn MacDonald is ahead, at least in the fwd spaces.
Jack Scrimshaw. He is super dependable, rarely makes mistakes and is so damaging by hand and foot. And geez can he take a contested mark!!?? People always go on about Sicily but Scrimma is just as reliable.Sicily is the top tier A grade Hawthorn backman for the fact he impacts more often with inside 50's and setting up scores himself but so often Scrimshaw begins those plays with an intercept karo or halving a contest and bringing the ball to ground and he impacts there too. Scrimma is criminally underrated. But not by Hawks members and faithful. We know his worth.
Welcome, Francis Evans, Saw his highlights package and I am impressed. Certainly knows where the goals are, and can nail a tackle. Welcome back, Terry, looking good mate and relaxed. Real shame about White and McMahon but if they hang in there, they will probably get a shot at it.
47 Comments
"he's a slow comer but he's come so quickly" from Gerard 😂 3:20
Love you Kane but Brent Daniels 🤣
Bro lost his team the Semi Final (and a Grand Final spot) by taking the advantage call
13 minutes, MORE PLEASE!!!
I don't know about Max Michalanney. Still a raw prospect, not the best defender. Think he's still got a ways to go. On that trajectory tho
Aiden Corr should be on this list.
Saved you a watch:
00:16 – Callum Wilkie
01:20 – Connor Macdonald
02:19 – Jack Buckley
03:25 – Willem Drew
04:28 – Max Michalanney
05:30 – Aliir Aliir
07:01 – Brandon Starcevich
08:32 – Will Powell
09:44 – Will Hayward
10:11 – Brent Daniels
1. Judd McVee
Z.Guth is 100% most underrated defender
18 clubs and Kane manages to name 2 port players, one of whom absolutely noone underates, and the other everyone reckons is a decent player
"There's only one Port player on the list you clown! What are you talking about? "……."Well two Port players actually." Classic Kane Cornes earning all the love he gets!
Trent rivers
what is the measure of determining whether player x is underrated? amount of times mentioned on TV, media articles, supercoach, state of club, break out season predicted? Most i/state clubs will generally have a lot of under the radar types who get the job done and do it well.
Holmes
No rowebottom is criminal
Could’ve pumped up a few more Port players, Kane.
It's not the 2 out 10 on the list as so much the problem, I can always fit Peter Matera, Jeremy McGovern and Josh Kennedy etc in my all time best 22. Everybody will always see 10-15% from their club of support or employment on the list with every ranking as fairly justified, it's the certainty of it which makes it pointless, because we know there's 1-2 players Kane didn't bother to truely look for and that's really the definition of finding underrated.
George Hewitt
When Port had Brendon Ah Chee i always wondered if it was possible we could get his little brother Callum Ah Chee over, as he looked very promising,
How is Allir Allir underrated?
Will Hayward is so loved internally at Sydney, that he hasn't finished in the top 10 of any of the past 4 Bob Skilton Medals.
No Collingwood players of course
McCluggage – one of the cleanest midfielders in the comp, equally damaging inside and outside, has played a massive role in Brisbane's rise from wooden-spooners in his first season to Premiers. Somehow never gets the plaudits he deserves (although to be fair, it's a stacked midfield at Brisbane and Neale takes most of the spotlight deservedly so)
Aliir Aliir is good, but in a one on one marking contest he does infringe more then get paid against him.
Drew so underrated even Corn forgot he'd included him
Brady Hough not being on this list is proof he is number 1
Puts Starc in the list, talks about Enright. 😅 Anything to avoid talking about the Lions
No Gerrard, the Swans are not thinking of playing McDonald back, you are. You have been on this bee in your bonnet ever since he kicked his first goal. He will play bloody forward Gerrard. McCartin might at some stages too. The idea is to ease players like Snell, Andrews and Hamling into the backs. With Rampe set to retire, and not playing tall anymore, these players need to step up and Logan is not in the mix. He sits in the forward line as the third tall, the Gunston role and he kicked 37 last season and will kick 50 next. But wait, there's more. I think Joel Amartey is the smokie here. I think he is the player capable of kicking the next 100. If he learns to be more consistent, his best is amazing, his worst is horrible, he will be a star.
I'd think about a Hardwick, Scrimshaw but I like the list overall. MacDonald is highly underrated, Mackenzie I think will actually be better in long run than Connor but rn MacDonald is ahead, at least in the fwd spaces.
Cant believe people hate on Kane. Best out there right now. 90% of takes are spot on.
Jack Scrimshaw. He is super dependable, rarely makes mistakes and is so damaging by hand and foot. And geez can he take a contested mark!!?? People always go on about Sicily but Scrimma is just as reliable.Sicily is the top tier A grade Hawthorn backman for the fact he impacts more often with inside 50's and setting up scores himself but so often Scrimshaw begins those plays with an intercept karo or halving a contest and bringing the ball to ground and he impacts there too. Scrimma is criminally underrated. But not by Hawks members and faithful. We know his worth.
Jack Scrimshaw from the Hawke stiff not to make this list he is very highly underrated
Surprised he didn't name 10 Poort players
Do not bother posting a video unless Kane is in it. Everyone else is so down the line boring.
3:22 please explain 🤔
Welcome, Francis Evans, Saw his highlights package and I am impressed. Certainly knows where the goals are, and can nail a tackle. Welcome back, Terry, looking good mate and relaxed. Real shame about White and McMahon but if they hang in there, they will probably get a shot at it.
Starc is a jet hope lions can keep him as the west teams will come hard. Ah Chee says hello btw 😮
Based on the group of players Aliir lumped with in the commentary, boardline overrated. Fairly rated is provavly correct
This is just a trojan horse for Cornes to whinge about Vic bias.
Alier is B+ defender. Alex Pearce and Luke Ryan are above him. McGovern, Andrews, weitering, above them again. Taylor is below Ryan.
The game is analysed to within an inch of its life these days, so not sure if you can have an underrated player😊
St Kilda would be bottom 3 without Callum Wilkie. One of the best mature ages we’ve ever picked up.
Gryan Miers has to be in this. One of the best kicks in the comp, just getting better.
Blake Hardwick from the Hawks is massively underrated.
The list goes on of under rated players. Media hysteria and laziness goes back to heralding the stars all the time.
Crazy there is only 2 players from a Vic team…
Whoever underrates Allir Allir is blind. The guy is anightmare for forwards. How did Sydney lose him to Port??
Hawks defence this year wont be underrated. Barass Battle Sicily Hardwick Jiath 🔥