LA Sued Over Mountain Lion Habitat Ruling on Golf Course Homes | Valley

LA Sued Over Mountain Lion Habitat Ruling on Golf Course Homes | Valley

Councilman Bob Blumenfield, who represents Woodland Hills, defended the decision, saying scientific assessments establish the property as habitat for the protected animals. His office said he does not oppose development at the site, but disputes whether the project qualifies for the approval process the developer wants.

State housing officials have separately challenged the city’s reasoning in a letter that could expose Los Angeles to increased court-imposed penalties. Planning officials said housing could still proceed at the property through discretionary review.

Attorneys for Yes In My Back Yard Law, Californians for Homeownership and the California Housing Defense Fund filed the lawsuit in Los Angeles County Superior Court. They are asking a judge to overturn the city’s Aug. 20 determination and require approval under AB 2011, the Affordable Housing and High Road Jobs Act.

According to the lawsuit, the law entitles qualifying housing developments to streamlined approval based on objective state standards, without years of discretionary hearings.

The plaintiffs allege city officials spent much of 2026 searching for ways to disqualify the development. They say the city voted to study narrowing Canoga Avenue to make the site ineligible, then pursued reclassifying golf courses as vacant land until city attorneys found that approach legally weak.

“A golf course is obviously not a mountain lion habitat,” Zachary Pitts, Los Angeles director of YIMBY Action, said in a statement.

Pitts added, “State laws like AB 2011 set objective standards so that it’s illegal for cities to invent new nonsense reasons to say no to new housing. Woodland Hills is the perfect neighborhood to build more homes — including dozens of affordable ones — and families deserve the chance to live in them.”

Blumenfield said the city evaluated the application on its merits and followed AB 2011. Under the law, he said, a site considered habitat for protected species does not qualify for ministerial processing, the expedited approval path at issue in the lawsuit.

“The scientific evidence is indisputable: biological and ecological experts, including the Mountains and Recreation Conservation Authority, have definitively concluded that this site is habitat for mountain lions,” Blumenfield said in a statement.

He added, “Relying on rigorous field assessments and empirical data, experts confirmed that the area supplies water, natural cover, and critical wildlife corridors necessary to sustain these apex predators. Any claim to the contrary ignores established ecological findings.”

“Furthermore National Park Service (NPS) researchers wrote a letter to clarify how their 2021 mountain lion study was cited in documents regarding the Woodland Hills Golf Course, correcting several scientific and factual misstatements by the developers,” Blumenfield concluded.

Jake Flynn, a spokesman for Blumenfield, told City News Service by email that the councilman does not oppose development on the property. Flynn said the issue is the developer’s use of an expedited state approval process.

Flynn also said the Department of City Planning issues determination letters knowing they could prompt lawsuits, and that the department and city attorney are prepared.

A representative for the City Attorney’s Office said the office does not comment on pending litigation.

The 398-home country club proposal would occupy 20 acres of the club’s 93-acre property at 21150 Dumetz Road. It is known as the 4868 Canoga Avenue project.

Owner and developer Arrium Capital, a Newport Beach-based real estate private equity firm, submitted its application to the Department of City Planning in November 2025. The proposal includes single-family homes and apartments, with 97 affordable units designated for seniors and families. Of those affordable units, 32 would serve seniors and 65 would serve families.

The single-family homes would reach up to three stories, while apartment buildings would rise up to four stories. Plans include approximately 835 vehicle parking spaces, internal streets and some green space, along with surface parking areas.

Residents concerned about the project’s safety have circulated petitions, held meetings and lobbied council members to oppose it. Blumenfield’s office has also sent letters to state lawmakers.

In addition to the habitat issue, Blumenfield has raised concerns about development in a residential area within a “very high” fire hazard severity zone.

Blumenfield’s office pointed to housing growth elsewhere in his district, saying the Third Council District grew more than any other district in the last census. City officials said tens of thousands of housing units have been built or approved in Warner Center and that every commercial corridor in the district has welcomed housing.

Housing Action Coalition, Abundant Housing LA and YIMBY Law have criticized Blumenfield’s efforts to prevent more housing construction while Los Angeles faces a housing shortage.

Separate from the application’s denial, the council voted 11-1 in August to direct city attorneys and planning staff to prepare changes to zoning rules for agricultural and residential areas designated A Zone. Specifically, council members requested an interim control ordinance to disallow public parking in A Zone within very high fire hazard severity zones or hillside areas.

If adopted, the ordinance would affect housing developments’ eligibility for incentives and streamlined approval under certain state laws, including AB 2011.

The requested ordinance remains under study. Planning officials said the department is researching topics related to the council’s instructions and has not yet transmitted a draft ordinance.

Councilwoman Nithya Raman, now mayor-elect, cast the lone opposing vote on the August instructions. Council members Hugo Soto-Martinez, Eunisses Hernandez and John Lee were absent.

“I have concerns about the precedent this proposed ordinance sets. The city should not change the rules in the middle of a submitted project being reviewed in order to strip that project of eligibility for a state-approved streamlining process,” Raman said in a statement at the time.

“Regardless of the merits of individual projects, this raises legal exposure for the city,” Raman added.

The California Department of Housing and Community Development challenged the city’s reasoning for denying the housing application in an Oct. 28 technical assistance letter concerning AB 2011.

In the four-page letter, signed by Melinda Coy, assistant deputy director of housing accountability, state officials said the city’s rationale “appears to improperly expand the statutory standard, effectively undermining the intent of AB 2011, and is not supported by the law.”

The warning could have financial consequences. AB 712, which took effect Jan. 1, 2026, increased penalties courts may impose on local governments that violate state housing laws after receiving advance notice. The department’s letter serves as that warning.

The state gave Los Angeles until Nov. 25 to respond before deciding whether to act.

The letter concluded, “HCD requests that the city review this correspondence and provide a written response no later than November 25, 2026. HCD will review and consider the city’s written response before taking any action…”

Editor’s Note: This story includes reporting from City News Service, a content partner of Westside Current.

Add a comment

Leave a Reply