A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration from closing East Potomac Park in Washington, D.C., delivering another legal setback to President Donald Trump’s plans to transform a historic public golf course into a championship-level facility.
U.S. District Judge Ana C. Reyes issued a temporary restraining order Saturday, preventing the government from closing East Potomac Park and East Potomac Golf Course beginning Sunday, as the administration had planned.
The order requires the park and golf course to remain open during the hours they were accessible to the public as of November 14, preserving public access while the legal battle continues.
Read More on News
Reyes found that the government’s stated justifications for closing the park—including safety concerns involving a deteriorating seawall and the golf course’s lack of an operator—were likely pretextual. The judge added that the administration appeared to be moving ahead with Trump’s redevelopment plans while offering alternative explanations for the closure.
“The Court, based on the current record, readily finds that these explanations are pretextual,” Reyes wrote.
She added that the government had likely violated at least the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) in its haste to meet the November 15 deadline.
Under Saturday’s court order, East Potomac Golf Course must remain accessible to the public, even if the government chooses not to operate it for golf. Other portions of the park, including Ohio Drive SW, must also remain open, with limited exceptions for immediate safety threats and areas where active seawall repairs require temporary restrictions.
The temporary restraining order remains in effect through November 28, or until further court order.
Newsweek has reached out to the White House for comment.
Trump Had Insisted Closure Would Begin Sunday
The ruling comes after Trump repeatedly insisted that East Potomac Golf Course would close November 15 to make way for redevelopment.
In an October 26 Truth Social post, Trump wrote: “We are closing the East Potomac Golf Course Site as scheduled on November 15th.”
He said the project would involve the development of a “World Championship Public Facility” capable of hosting major tournaments, including the U.S. Open, PGA Championship, Ryder Cup and Presidents Cup.
On Saturday, Trump renewed his criticism of the existing course, which he has repeatedly dubbed “Trash Island,” while promising that Washington-area residents would receive a 50 percent discount on rates at the rebuilt facility.
“Very importantly, also, is that anyone living in the D.C. area will be given a 50% discount on any and all Rates charged,” Trump wrote.
He did not explain how eligibility for the discount would be determined or when it would take effect.
Trump also attacked Reyes, writing that she did not want the administration to “quickly and inexpensively fix up the Course.”
The judge’s latest order, however, prevents the administration from proceeding with the planned public closure on Sunday.
Judge Questions Administration’s Safety Arguments
At a Friday hearing, Reyes questioned why the administration needed to close nearly all of East Potomac Park, including roads, walking trails, fishing areas, playgrounds and picnic spaces, rather than restrict access to specific areas requiring repairs.
The government argued that the closure was necessary because the golf course would no longer have an operator after the National Park Service ended National Links Trust’s management agreement and because the surrounding seawall presented safety concerns.
Reyes questioned why those conditions, some of which had existed for years, suddenly required an extensive closure beginning on the exact date Trump had publicly specified.
The judge noted that the National Park Service had identified seawall safety concerns as far back as 2019 but had previously addressed them by fencing off hazardous sections rather than closing the entire park.
She also highlighted that more than 30,000 runners had been permitted to participate in a marathon around the park just three days before the administration announced the planned closure.
Government counsel argued that an organized race in daylight did not present the same risks as individuals walking near the seawall at night.
Reyes said that explanation did not establish why nearly the entire park needed to close indefinitely.
“Even so, this does not explain why NPS now chooses to close almost the entire Park, at all hours, for an indefinite period,” she said, according to court filings.
The judge also questioned why the government had not considered less restrictive alternatives, including finding another golf course operator or allowing the National Park Service to manage the course itself.
“The Government proposes to close a historic park, daily enjoyed by Washingtonians of all stripes, indefinitely,” Reyes wrote. “This closure would irreparably harm Plaintiffs, who use the Park regularly for recreational activities.”
Another Setback in Trump’s Golf Course Battle
The ruling represents the latest development in an increasingly contentious legal dispute over Trump’s plans for the 106-year-old public golf course.
The DC Preservation League and two local golfers sued the Interior Department, National Park Service and federal officials in February, arguing that the administration’s redevelopment plans violate federal environmental and historic-preservation requirements.
The plaintiffs have also argued that the land is protected for public recreational use and that the administration’s plans threaten its historic character.
The dispute escalated in October after the National Park Service removed hundreds of trees at the course, prompting Reyes to issue an order restricting further tree removal and requiring advance notification of certain work.
In an earlier ruling, Reyes questioned the administration’s environmental review, saying the potential impact of the work had not been adequately studied and that the project’s budget remained unclear.
The judge’s latest order further restricts the administration’s ability to move forward with the closure, although it does not prevent the government from undertaking necessary repairs or imposing limited restrictions to address specific, imminent safety threats.
The court specifically allowed temporary closures in areas immediately surrounding active seawall repairs where restrictions are necessary to protect public safety.
Judge Previously Ordered Investigation Into DOJ Conduct
The latest ruling follows another extraordinary development in the case. Earlier this month, Reyes appointed former U.S. Attorney Jessie Liu to investigate whether Trump administration officials and government lawyers made misleading statements or violated professional conduct rules during the litigation.
The inquiry followed questions about whether National Park Service officials had been instructed to omit information from court declarations and whether government witnesses had accurately described the administration’s existing plans for the course.
Reyes expressed concern about what she described as “materially misleading information” provided to the court.
At the time, the judge emphasized that she had not made a finding of misconduct.
Trump has repeatedly attacked Reyes over her decisions, including warning that she would be held “fully responsible” if anyone were hurt or killed at the course.
The president has also described the existing facility as “dangerous, dilapidated, and absolutely disgusting.” The Trump administration has argued that its redevelopment would improve the facility, attract major sporting events and generate economic activity for Washington.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Hannah Parry and Cristina Diciu.