Listed agricultural firm Kakuzi PLC has lost its fight to reclaim 72 acres of land used by Makuyu Club as a golf course after the Supreme Court dismissed its appeal challenging the club’s ownership through adverse possession.
The apex court upheld the Court of Appeal’s decision, noting that Makuyu Club had demonstrated continuous, uninterrupted and exclusive occupation of the disputed land for the period required by law, while Kakuzi failed to take unequivocal steps to assert its ownership within the prescribed limitation period.
The court said the evidence showed that the club had occupied the land from 1934, with Kakuzi’s knowledge, and continued using it after the agricultural company acquired the expansive property in 1967.
“The respondent (Makuyu Club), thereafter, remained in continuous, uninterrupted, and exclusive possession of the land until 2002, when, after a period of approximately thirty-five (35) years, it instituted proceedings seeking to acquire title by way of adverse possession,” the court said.
The judges further found that a subsequent owner must assert ownership through unequivocal acts capable of interrupting the adverse possessor’s occupation.
“We are satisfied that the appellant (Kakuzi) failed to do so within the prescribed limitation period,” the court ruled.
The Supreme Court said Kakuzi sat back and only sought to assert its interest in May 2002, when, by its own account, it attempted to formalise the club’s use of the property through a lease agreement.
The decision brings to an end Kakuzi’s latest attempt to overturn a series of judgments recognising Makuyu Club’s claim to the land through adverse possession.
The dispute centres on approximately 72 acres of land in Murang’a County that Makuyu Club has used as a golf course for decades.
The club maintains that the property was donated by white settlers in 1934 for use as a golf course, long before Kakuzi acquired the larger parcel of land in 1967.
It subsequently moved to court in 2002, seeking to be declared the lawful owner of the disputed portion on grounds that it had occupied the land for more than 12 years.
Kakuzi, however, challenged the claim, arguing that the club’s occupation had always been with the knowledge and express consent of the company and its predecessor.
The firm maintained that the club had initially entered the land as a ‘donee’ and that its use of the property was permissive rather than adverse to the owner’s interests.
It argued that time could not run in favour of a party whose occupation originated from consent or donation, particularly where the land had subsequently changed ownership.
The company also contended that it had continuously taken steps to affirm its proprietary rights and that an agreement was being negotiated in May 2001 to formalise the club’s use of the land through a lease.
According to Kakuzi, the club’s management instead filed the suit before the negotiations were completed.
“Informal arrangement”
Makuyu Club, through David Mereka, disputed the existence of an informal arrangement between the parties. It maintained that the land had been donated for use as a golf course in 1934 and that Kakuzi, after acquiring the property in 1967, had failed to take steps to assert its ownership over the portion occupied by the club.
In its appeal to the Supreme Court, Kakuzi sought a determination on whether a claim for adverse possession could succeed where the initial occupation of land arose from consent or donation by an owner, without a transfer of title, and where ownership subsequently changed hands.
The company argued that the club’s occupation was permissive and that such use could not satisfy the legal requirements for adverse possession.
It maintained that it was in the public interest for the court to clarify that the elements of adverse possession exclude the permissive use of land.
Kakuzi also wanted the court to determine whether informal arrangements governing land use, including charitable rights to use property, could give rise to claims of adverse possession.
The company argued that it had not abandoned its proprietary interests and had supported the club’s continued use of the golf course over the years.
Among the activities it cited were supplying diesel, petrol and lubricants, lending tractors and lawnmowers, paying wages for clubhouse watchmen and golf course employees, and providing equipment such as coats and torches.
In dismissing Kakuzi’s challenge, the Court of Appeal had held that supplying water and grass mowers, paying workers, making donations and providing other assistance did not constitute an assertion of ownership capable of interrupting the club’s occupation.
The company subsequently escalated the dispute to the Supreme Court, seeking to overturn the finding that the club had acquired ownership through long-term occupation.
[email protected]