What was Pat Riley thinking?!

What was Pat Riley thinking?!



We all make mistakes, it’s true. I once bit into a bar of baker’s chocolate, nobody’s perfect. Even if their hair implies otherwise. Talking about you and your perfectly slicked back head, Pat Riley. Because even the multi-champion coach made mistakes– one so bad it cost the New York Knicks a title.

Real quick, if you enjoy this then may I recommend Clara diving deep into a basketball musical written by the confusing, enigmatic GM Daryl Morey: https://www.patreon.com/SecretBase/posts/musical-about-152397990

Game 7 of the 1994 NBA Finals, John Starks was ice-cold. He went 2-for-18! And Riley never took him out of the game! The coach had fresh shooters on the bench! What was he thinking?! We may never know, but we gotta try to figure it out.

Written and Produced by: Clara Morris
Directed and Edited by: Jiazhen Zhang

Subscribe: http://goo.gl/Nbabae
Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/secretbase
Follow us on Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/secretbase.bsky.social
Follow us on Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@secretbasesbn?
Check out our full video catalog: http://goo.gl/9pMHRV
Visit our playlists: http://goo.gl/NvpZFF
Explore SB Nation: http://www.sbnation.com

View Comments (46)
  1. The New York Knicks teams of Pat Riley and Jeff Van Gundy were contenders throughout the 1990s.
    Can't hate on Starks since you saw what he brought to the table. Hubert Davis was the better shooter, but Starks play just elevated the team.
    Starks is my favorite Knick of all time but his continued chucking and Riley’s inability to coach him through the slump or play Davis who was a nasty spot up shooter instead cost us the chip.

  2. Ok…who else is going to be out on the floor that night? Sometimes it's up to the players to get it right.

    What you should be more annoyed with is that game 7 was still close. Starks alone didn't lose game 7. The Knicks could have won that game hundreds of times. The Rockets took advantage, the Knicks didn't.

  3. A 5th hypothesis that I'm not sure applies here but bears mentioning is the concept that a player can shoot themselves out of a slump. A player can start ice cold but get red hot as the game goes on and a coach might conceivably leave a streaky player in to see if that will happen.

  4. Riley loves "Blue collar players " . Physically gifted players have to prove they work hard , as bench player Pat Riley did. It is a bench player mentality. They think if they only had "your gifts" they would be unstoppable. It makes players like Shaq & LeBron not his favorites.
    John starks stayed in ..North Carolina tar heel Hebert Davis made 1 mistake..you sir are out. Smh

  5. Doc Rivers and Hubert Davis were more PGs than SGs. Also Davis was too much of a nice guy to fit in with the Knicks tough guy ethos. Another side note, Popovich and Kerr had the opposite philosophy about wives and family traveling with players.

  6. John Starks will always be my favorite Knick. When 2K was actually a game that was fun to play (2k10) I always made a version of Starks in My Player and DESTROYED.

    It wasn't on John what happened in this game. It is and will always be the Hubris of Riley and the transient and inconvenient poor play of Ewing.
    Charles Smith had it worse than Starks. TWO STRAIGHT missed put backs from UNDER the hoop by a near 7 foot tall man.

    Riley is not a good coach. He is a motivational speaker.

  7. I think it's a mix of several factors. Riley being such a control freak, that the Lakers that won several titles with him rebelled against him and ran him out of town. Plus I think that he really did believe that Starks would heat up. Starks is the streakiest shooter that I've ever seen. He can miss 9 in a row and then drop 6 straight. He's either bricking his team into oblivion or an unstoppable shooter.

    I think that there is another aspect to it though, with evidence for it going through his entire coaching and front office career. Riley likes underdogs. Starks was an underdog. He came from the CBA. The CBA was the minor league of basketball. The G league before the G league. Riley likes those guys. Look at Gabe Vincent. Kurt Rambis. Another guy whose stats don't jump out on paper, and if he was on any other team in the NBA, probably would have been cut from the roster. Look at what Riley is doing right now in Miami. They traded half the team for Giannis, and now Giannis is surrounded by a lot of underdogs.

    Now look at Riley the player. He was an underdog. He barely played and only lasted 7 years.

  8. Not a Knicks fan. I know Starks was always super emotional, but his reaction to each missed shot seems to get worse and worse. Was he always like that? He looks inconsolable/on the verge of tears.

  9. The Knicks only trailed by 3 points heading into the 4th quarter. I don't know how much of Starks' 2-18 (0-11 from three!) had come in the first three quarters, but Riley probably figured the Knicks were in good shape if he could have found his range in the 4th quarter.

  10. Oh another national media version of dumping on that Rockets championship team; ignoring the accomplishments of that team and the subsequent repeat.

    Instead of celebrating how good that Rockets team was; their accomplishments are diminished and chalked up to bad coaching decisions from someone else. Why not a video of how Tomjanovic handled those teams? How they beat the Suns teams? Or how they came from way back in Finals of Game 1 of the following year in Orlando? How Clutch City came around?

    But no. It has to be about how the Knicks failed. This is a Knicks loss wrapped up in a "The Real Wives.." style of drama and excuses.

    You complete set of biased muppets. Boo. BOOOOOOO. Go Hellhole! (go look up that reference in the columns of the NYT, it was before your time and you clearly can't be bothered to do the research)

  11. If the Knicks had won that series, Starks would have been named the MVP. People forget the only reason NY didn't win it in six games was Olajuwon got a fingernail on Starks' last shot that could have won it for the Knicks at the end of Game Six. No one could have expected Starks would end up THAT cold at the end of Game Seven.

  12. Now I see where Doc Rivers got the no wives allowed rule and that’s what killed the chances of the Orlando Magic being good in the early 2000s Tracy McGrady, Tim Duncan and Grant Hill

  13. Surprised you didn't mention Starks' defense. He did make the NBA All Defensive Second Team the year prior, and a 35 year old Blackman would likely struggle with quicker perimeter guys like Smith and Maxwell. Perhaps Riley wanted him on the other end of the floor and was just hoping he just wouldn't shoot so much.

  14. I blame the Knicks GM for not getting Ewing a consistent scorer, a shooter.

    John Starks was streaky…live by the streak….you know the rest.

    Knicks were down by only 3 at the start of the 4th quarter. Derek Harper had the hot hand.

    That's why if you go to John Starks Kia in Queens, beware. Only 2 of the 18 Kias sold there are legit, the rest are lemons.

  15. CLARA, SETH, JOE, WILL, & FRIENDS….I GOT SOME IDEAS!

    Rewinder: 2006 Orange Bowl (PSU vs FSU 3OTs)
    Beef History: Eric Lindros vs Philadelphia Flyers Organization (Bobby Clarke)
    Big Deal/Rewinder: the 1992 Lindros trade
    Rewinder: George Foreman wins the Heavyweight championship at 45
    Big Deal: the greatest NFL coach of all time (Belichick) and the greatest College Football coach of all time (Saban) facing each other 4 times between 2005 and 2006.
    Beef History: Michael Jordan and Isiah Thomas
    Beef History: Phil Jackson and Pat Riley
    Untitled: Barry Sanders
    Collapse: Early 90s Buffalo Bills
    Collapse: 1987-2000 Florida State Seminoles
    Collapse: Moneyball (2002) Oakland Athletics
    Rewinder: 1994 Orange Bowl (FSU vs Nebraska)
    Rewinder: Dale Earnhardt Sr FINALLY wins the Daytona 500
    Rewinder: Richard Petty’s 200th win
    Rewinder: 2012 Olympic 100m Men’s Final
    Rewinder: The Catch By Willie
    Rewinder: FSU’s Wide Right I, FSU’s Wide Right II
    Rewinder/Big Deal: NHL’s The Trade
    Rewinder: Phantom Foul (Game 6, NBA Finals)
    Rewinder: Webber’s Timeout
    Collapse: Edmonton Dynasty
    Collapse: Islanders Dynasty

    New Series Suggestion: the First Ring 💍 (where you talk about pro or college players/coaches finally getting their first ring after years of turmoil)

    New Series Suggestion: the Untimely End (players/coaches who careers suddenly end before any expected (ex: Megatron) or ended in a way that few expected (ex: Woody Hayes))

    New Series Suggestion: What Happened (when organizations and or teams ruin great thing going for no reason (ex: Nebraska’s dynasty))

    New Series Suggestion: the Road Back (teams who were featured in collapsed episodes that ultimately built their way back to the top (ex: Knicks)

Leave a Reply