Robot Tested: The Best Golf Balls of 2025 (MyGolfSpy Results!)
You might think the golf ball you use doesn’t matter — but robot testing proves otherwise. In this video I react to the brand-new MyGolfSpy 2025 Golf Ball Test, break down the data, and show you why the ball in your bag could be costing you distance, spin, and consistency.
Heres the MyGolfSpy full article: https://mygolfspy.com/buyers-guides/all/2025-golf-ball-test/
We’ll cover:
⛳ Why “soft is slow”… but not always (Callaway Supersoft surprise) https://amzn.to/4fOtufM
⛳ The biggest performance gaps show up in your wedges, not your driver
⛳ Budget balls like TaylorMade Tour Response that outperformed $50+ tour balls https://amzn.to/3VhR8YA
⛳ Why swing speed changes everything in ball fitting
⛳ Kirkland v3.5 — the comeback we’ve been waiting for (and yes, we’ll cut it open 👀) https://amzn.to/4lP677f
👉 If you want to find the right golf ball for your game, this video will help you make smarter choices — and maybe save you money.
Have you played either of these balls?
If you want your full guide on golf ball compression to help you choose the perfect golf ball then check out the link below:
** Get your Golf Ball Compression Guide here:
https://bit.ly/upclosegolf
** 10% DISCOUNT OFF USED GOLF BALLS **
https://www.golfballplanet.com/?ref=13409
(Use code FUNGOLF)
** 10% off Lake Balls with Mail Order Golf UK **
https://mailordergolf.com/?ref=fungolfuk
(Use code FUNGOLF)
Be sure to subscribe and let me know in the comments below 👍🏌️♂️
Welcome to Close Up Golf, your one-stop-shop for detailed reviews of the latest golf equipment.
Here, we take you closer to the golf gear than you’ve ever been, meticulously examining and explaining every detail that can influence your game. Our reviews range from clubs, balls, bags, to golf clothing and more, making it easier for you to navigate the vast world of golf equipment.
Whether you’re a seasoned pro seeking to upgrade your gear, you’ll find the guidance and clarity you need on our channel. It’s not just about the renowned brands; we love uncovering lesser-known gems in the industry and introducing them to our viewers.
In addition to our content, we highly recommend you visit Fun Golf at https://fungolf.co.uk/.
Subscribe, turn on your notifications, and never miss out on the finest golf equipment on the market. Your journey to enhanced golfing begins right here on Close Up Golf. You’re just one swing away from your best golf purchase decision.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please be aware, if you click on the links above I will earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on a link provided and make a purchase, I might receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
This helps support my work and allows me to continue to provide valuable content to my audience. Thank you for your support
◽️◽️◽️◽️◽️◽️
⬇️ More stuff you should check out ⬇️
** 10% DISCOUNT OFF USED GOLF BALLS **
https://www.golfballplanet.com/?ref=13409
(Use code FUNGOLF)
** 10% off Lake Balls with Mail Order Golf UK **
https://mailordergolf.com/?ref=fungolfuk
(Use code FUNGOLF)
** 15% DISCOUNT OFF SHOT SCOPE PRODUCTS **
https://bit.ly/3FLnu7C
(Use code FUNGOLF)
** CHECK OUT OUR AMAZON SHOP FOR RECOMENDED ITEMS **
https://www.amazon.com/shop/fungolfuk
** VISIT THE FUN GOLF WEBSITE **
https://fungolf.co.uk/
Now, you might think that a golf ball you use doesn’t make any difference to your game. Well, in this video, I’ll show you that it definitely does. And isn’t just me saying it. My golf spy who’ve just tested every top golf ball said there’s more difference between golf balls than there are between drivers, irons, or wedges. So, if you’ve ever thought that the golf ball you use doesn’t matter, you might need to think again. So, on this channel, I’ve reviewed and cut open over 300 golf balls. I try and show you exactly how much they can impact your game. And today I’m reacting to the brand new My Golf Spy Ball Test with some honest thoughts. I’ll be cutting some golf balls open with Jeff. And if you stick to the end, I’ll even be recommending some of the golf balls that you should maybe add to your bag this year. My Golf Spar have been testing golf balls for over 5 years now. Every test is run using a robot at multiple swing speeds to eliminate human error. They use launch monitors like Trackman and GC Quad to track every shot. This year they tested 44 models of golf ball which took them over 80 hours. They measured things like distance, spin, consistency, dispersion, and trajectory. It’s one of the most comprehensive looks of golf ball performance you’ll find anywhere. And golf ball nerds like me wait for it like Christmas day every time it’s released. And while no test is perfect, it gives us a really strong baseline for comparing one ball to another. And in this video, I’ll share with you some of the themes that I learned from it, what could help you with your game, and I’ll even give you a top three golf balls to stick in your bag. The first big theme that was confirmed to me was that soft is slow. Now, I’ve talked about that on this channel, but my golf spice testing reinforced the idea that soft is slow. Softer, lower compression balls usually mean less ball speed. But here’s the interesting bit for me. it was that the Callaway Super Soft, which is a soft golf ball, actually performed better than expected this year. Firstly, it held its own in distance at mid swing speeds. It wasn’t the shortest of the irons, even compared to firmer balls. And for a budget friendly, low compression option, it’s surprisingly competitive for golfers with slower swing speeds. With a compression of less than 50, it’s a very soft compression ball. And when you cut it open, you can see it’s a two-piece ball. And it’s not scientific, but that low compression core does feel soft. Now, I’m happy to hold my hands up and say that I’ve criticized this ball quite a bit on this channel this year for inconsistent cores when I’ve cut them open, even on the newer models. But in robot testing, it really held up. So, credit where it’s due. It’s definitely one to have a closer look at this year. And maybe don’t always listen to me. Then, the next big theme was that spin differences show up most in wedges. Maybe no surprise, but my golf spy found that the biggest differences in golf balls aren’t always off the driver. They’re in the wedge shots. So, that’s where you can see spin gaps of nearly 4,000 RPM between some balls. Take the Tailor Made TB5 in the 35 yard robot testing. It showed it’s one of the spinniest balls in the lineup with over 6,000 RPM. And versus the Tireless Velocity, which had an RPM of just over 2,000, you can see there’s a big difference. And when we cut them open and put them side by side, you can see the differences in the construction of these two golf balls. One is a firm, high compression ball with a urethane cover that grabs the grooves like crazy compared to that two-piece Iron Titus Velocity golf ball. And the difference around the green is night and day. Now, the next theme, which came through loud and clear, and my golf spy hammered home is that you don’t need to spend $50 plus to get a good ball. And the standout golf ball here was the Kirkland Performance Plus version 3.5. Now, let’s be honest. Since that legendary 2016 original version, Kirkland’s golf balls have gone downhill. Version two and three were inconsistent, spinny, and just not up to scratch. But this new one, quite simply, it’s the best Kirkland since the first one. Robot testing shows it’s longer and straighter than a Prov1 off the driver with plenty of stopping power on your wedges. This could be a serious contender to the Prov1. And when I cut it open with the help of Jeff, you can see that three-piece construction. And I really like the new blue color versus the yellow on the older version. Now, it’s not perfect, but at under $20 a dozen, it’s seriously impressive. And don’t worry, I’ll be taking a much closer look at this ball in future videos. So, be sure to subscribe so you don’t miss that video. Now, before I tell you about my gripes that I have and the other readers have had, there’s one golf ball which stood out which I wasn’t surprised about at all. The Tailor Made Tour Response. Now, I’ve been praising this golf ball all year. It’s one of the best value tour level options out there. And surprise, surprise, it performed brilliantly in robot testing. The robot testing showed is one of the strongest all round performers, offering excellent distance of the driver with lower spin than many of its tour level competitors while still maintaining playable spin and control through the irons. What stood out most was its consistency across swing speeds. It wasn’t just a budget option. It actually matched or outperformed several premium golf balls in key categories like carry distance and trajectory. So for golfers who want tourlike performance without tour like prices, the Tour Response Golf Ball continues to look like one of the smartest buys in the game. It’s sometimes nice when the data lines up with what I’ve seen on the course. Now along with other readers, I do have a couple of gripes with the Testo. First up, missing brands. I’d love to have seen Legato, Snell, Encore, Trust, and maybe LA Golf included. These get mentioned in my comment section a lot. golfers are actually buying and playing these balls, so why not test them, too? Next was the swing speed issue. Now, this was shared by a number of people in the comment section on their website, but they used 102 mph as their mid swing speed. Now, that’s quick. The average male amateur is closer to 93, 95 mph. So, while these numbers are helpful, they might not reflect what most of us are doing on the course. So, overall, my golf spy testing proves the golf ball matters. And whether you’re spending $50 on a Prov1 or $20 on a Kirkland, the ball you choose can change your game more than you think. If you want standouts across all swing speeds, their data points to three big performers. First up, Titus Pro1. Still the gold standard for consistency and all round performance. It wasn’t the longest in every category, but it remained the most reliable and tightly built, making it the safe pick for any and almost all golfers. Next up, the Strickson Zstar Diamond, highlighted for its excellent spin performance, particularly with wedges, while still holding its own for distance. My golf spy consistently called it one of the best allrounders. And finally, the Tailor-Made Tour response. While not always in the absolute top three, it was consistently flagged as one of the best value for performance golf balls in the test. I’ve been recommending this golf ball all year, so I’m really pleased about it. Now, I’ve added a link below for the full My Golf Spite article, so be sure to let me know what you think of that in the comments below. I’ll be cutting open more of these golf balls soon.

17 Comments
Have you seen the MyGolfSpy golf ball test results? What’s your top choice in golf ball? 🤔🏌️♂️
I watched the mygolfspy video and you should have mentioned PXG. It scored better than the response .
I have had a good look at the article and yes I think they need to do more testing from more brands. I have tried a lot of balls in the last 2 years, I have played from Pro V1 X to Noodles, I prefer a 3 piece ball, 2 piece I find clicky off the putter and irons, 4 + piece balls are costly but they are great around the greens. I did try the taylormade tour response, if you like a high flight ball or you need a higher flight ball then it’s for you. I found it ballooning on me and I lost distance. I play Maxfli Tour now, good spin around the green soft off the putter, lower flight off the driver, one down side is it marks easy. I am not a big fan of Kirkland balls. Keep cutting up the balls Jeff.👍🏌️♂️🇨🇦
I feel ball to cost ratio,the Wilson triad is still the best allrounder,all lot of golf balls are only usually different by just a yard anyway etc 😊
My golf spy only test and recommends tour balls that cost top dollar for swing speed of 102 mph it doesn't show any budget balls for swing speed 90 to 97 mph were the majority of everyday golfers come in
I average 108 mph and can max out at 115, but I can’t get past 310 yards. How come the robot with 116 mph is hitting over 322
Need more tests for people in the under 80MpH range
Tp5X stripe is a great call
I was surprised that some of the highest compression balls performed the best for mid-swing speed. Wilson Staff, Callaway Chrome Tour, Srixon Z-Star ZV all performed amazingly well and all over 90 compression.
Hell I'll subscribe to you. Thx for the summary. Don't think you can tell how good a ball will be by analysing its inside though
Taylormade tour response balls are great performers. Just durability on them sucks.
I have a mid iron and low driver speed – seems like super soft is the best for me as I want to pick up distance. Would you agree based on your reading of the data?
Hi Geoff nice look at the my Spy results👍, Why didn’t you list the slow swing Driver results 🤔, I’m a senior golfer with a Swing speed of 77mph play off 8hcp & 78year old, play ProV1x, the only other Balls in my testing that are as good for Distance and Control are Callaway Chrome Tour X, & Maxfly Tour X, when you have a slow swing speed you need height & Spin to get Max Distance (why can’t most tester’s see this🤔Thanks Dickey
I would ask about top flight balls, but considering how many I find in the bushes….
The test is good, but they should set the robot to 3 different style swings, because some golf balls will react very differently with a slice/draw or hitting up or down with the driver 👍
Ha ha my name
Is actually Jeff 😊
Not only do we have the MGS golf ball test but also the Today's Golfer test.
Both tests are excellent in methodology but utterly hopeless at statistical analysis and crucially never take into account statistically significance.
Let us start with the mantra that "soft is slow" something MGS has been pushing for years with absolutely no statistically significant evidence to back it up. Both MGS and Today's Golfer need to employ a professional statistician to determine the correct test for statistical significance and apply it to the data. Without that work being done then it is more than likely that ball speed differences from the average are simply testing chance.
Spin is more interesting. There are massive differences in wedge spin in the MGS data, not so much in the Today's Golfer data.
But where I agree with MGS, you do not need to spend a fortune to get a great ball.