Which takeaway should I stick with for consistency?

Hey everyone, I’ve been working on my takeaway and could use some feedback.

In one video (left), I’m trying to pull the club a bit more inside during the takeaway. In the other video (right), I’m just letting the club go more straight back.

Both swings can produce a pretty straight ball flight overall, but I feel like in the video on the right I’m coming way too far over the top.

For long-term improvement and consistency, which takeaway direction would be better to stick with? Appreciate any thoughts or similar experiences!