Did VAR Audio Steer Referee Towards VAR Call Over Celtic ‘Goal’ Against Hibs? Scottish Cup Quarter-Finals Fallout and VAR Controversy Following Willie Collum’s Monthly Review
Get tickets for An Evening with Neil Lennon 14th March: https://plzsoccer.com/an-evening-with-neil-lennon/an-evening-with-neil-lennon-14th-march/
🔥 Big Talking Points from The Show
1️⃣ Scottish Cup Quarter-Finals Recap & Semi-Final Preview
2️⃣ VAR Controversy: Willie Collum’s Monthly Review & Alan Muir’s Decision-Making
3️⃣ Celtic’s Dominance & Maeda’s Player of the Year Credentials
4️⃣ Aberdeen’s Cup Run & The Battle for Third Place
5️⃣ Rangers vs. Fenerbahçe: European Glory on the Horizon?
6️⃣ Ethan Walker’s Inspiring Journey – ‘Make It to Munich’ Documentary
7️⃣ Pressure on Arteta & Arsenal’s Title Race Collapse
⚖️ VAR Controversy & Alan Muir’s Decision
Willie Collum praised for transparency in reviewing key decisions.
Daizen Maeda’s goal vs. Hibs should not have been ruled out—no definitive angle proving the ball was out.
⚽ Celtic March On – Can Anyone Stop Them?
Celtic 2-0 Hibs – A controlled performance at Parkhead.
Maeda the Star Man: 27 goals this season – clear Player of the Year favorite.
Hibs lacked belief and quality in the final third.
Tam McManus: 📢 “Hibs gave it a go, but you need to believe you can win at Parkhead. They didn’t.”
Peter Martin: 📢 “Celtic have gears. If Hibs had scored, Celtic would have stepped up again.”
The focus now shifts to Celtic vs. Rangers in the league after Rangers’ Europa League clash against Fenerbahce at Ibrox.
⚔️ Aberdeen’s Scottish Cup Statement Win
A
berdeen 4-1 Queen’s Park – A professional display at Pittodrie.
Miovski & Duk shine upfront – Should Miovski be in the Scotland squad?
Third place race: Hibs vs. Aberdeen – Who finishes higher?
Peter Martin: 📢 “Aberdeen won comfortably. They’re hitting form at the right time.”
Tam McManus: 📢 “Miovski is looking sharp. Scotland need in-form strikers—why not call him up?”
Alison McConnell: 📢 “The battle for third is so close. Hibs and Aberdeen both have a chance.”
🇪🇺 Rangers vs Fenerbahce: Europa League
Rangers take a 3-1 lead into the second leg vs. Fenerbahçe.
Barry Ferguson’s tactical masterclass in Istanbul—can they finish the job at Ibrox?
Alan Rough: 📢 “If Rangers keep 11 men on the park, they go through 100%.”
Peter Martin: 📢 “Fenerbahçe need to come out and attack—that plays into Rangers’ hands.”
Tam McManus: 📢 “If Rangers score first, it’s over. The crowd will take care of the rest.”
Win vs. Fenerbahçe → Celtic at the weekend:
Does a long European night impact their domestic form?
Can they carry momentum into the Old Firm game?
The Football Show Highlights:
00:00:00 Intro – PLZ Soccer’s The Football Show LIVE
00:01:17 SFA VAR Monthly Review
00:11:45 Hearts 3-1 Dundee – “A stonewall penalty”
00:14:49 Celtic 2-0 Hibs – “What a season Maeda is having”
00:23:01 Celtic vs Rangers – “Celtic have a huge advantage”
00:25:38 David Gray Post Match Interview – “Hibernian are capable of 3rd”
00:29:22 Maeda PFA Player of the Year – “Can anyone stop Maeda?”
00:30:25 Scottish Premiership News – “Lennon Miller valued at £10 million”
00:32:00 Scottish Cup Semi Finals at Hampden – “It’s a good atmosphere when full”
00:32:44 Aberdeen 4-1 Queen’s Park – “No way Aberdeen would underestimate them”
00:38:23 Che Adams and Scotland strikers – “We just don’t have one”
00:41:06 Hearts 3-1 Dundee – “Dundee need to tighten up defensively”
00:46:58 Scottish Cup Semi Finals Draw – “Celtic vs Hearts in the final”
00:48:25 Rangers vs Fenerbahce – “Barry Ferguson has a real chance”
00:53:50 Make it to Munich Documentary
00:58:45 Mikel Arteta Arsenal – “He’s failed and the Premier League title is gone”
More to Watch:
Best football club team of all time: https://youtu.be/T5uwaSTE6ZU?si=VEwMrH0KE6Zw04_Y
Henrik Larsson Dream Team: https://youtu.be/rFd5Yd08_Oc
Ian Durrant on his bust-up with Graeme Souness: https://youtu.be/XI7dE1ooR5c
Martin O’Neill “I’ve never forgiven Jose Mourinho”: https://youtu.be/HIRkTHwD6Gc
Martin O’Neill on his time at Celtic: https://youtu.be/in25WpJJnI0
Neil Lennon one-to-one interview: https://youtu.be/RMtX1MpB-70
David Martindale behind the scenes at Livingston: https://youtu.be/6yI6psxcfGE
Lisbon Lion Berti Auld interview: https://youtu.be/7x1ONLU8Z0s
Gordon Strachan’s Dream Team: https://youtu.be/Zs3Qt3oi1nM
VISIT PLZ SOCCER HERE:
SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/c/plzsoccer?sub_confirmation=1
FACEBOOK: https://Facebook.com/plzsoccer
X: https://twitter.com/plzsoccer
WEBSITE: https://www.plzsoccer.com
#rangersfc #celtic #spfl #football #scottishfootball #philippeclement #rangers
31 Comments
Alison desperately trying to defend Celtic
Sack Muir now, a blatant case of match fixing.
You can always tell when the old firm game is on the horizon, Celtic players getting “linked” with other clubs. AJ last week and now CCV 🤦♂️
No wonder PLZ is banned grow up Peter.
Peter back tracking noo…
The ball was clearly out
My go to show for Scottish football ⚽️
Why is it these debates only ever happen when it goes against Celtic or Rangers?
More to Watch:
Henrik Larsson Dream Team: https://youtu.be/rFd5Yd08_Oc
Ian Durrant on his bust-up with Graeme Souness: https://youtu.be/XI7dE1ooR5c
Martin O'Neill "I've never forgiven Jose Mourinho": https://youtu.be/HIRkTHwD6Gc
Martin O'Neill on his time at Celtic: https://youtu.be/in25WpJJnI0
Neil Lennon one-to-one interview: https://youtu.be/RMtX1MpB-70
David Martindale behind the scenes at Livingston: https://youtu.be/6yI6psxcfGE
Lisbon Lion Berti Auld interview: https://youtu.be/7x1ONLU8Z0s
Gordon Strachan's Dream Team: https://youtu.be/Zs3Qt3oi1nM
Should be explained with decision on day by match ref. Not a month later by a retired ref. Com.
Honestly does Peter ever shut up? He makes a question last 5 minutes, gives the guest about 10 seconds to answer then jumps back in again. Brutal
Cheers lads 👍
Now I know why I never watch this show…Forever afraid of the controversy of anything always agreeing with the status quo and general consensus of societal mendacity.. in this particular video of utterly dismissing and ridiculing any legitimate reasoning of BIAS by some commentators as idiotic and ignorant and absurd… For anyone media or otherwise is absolute crass to assume that biased decisions of referring in the SFA , SPFL doesn’t exist is moronic and cowardly to say the least… History in the bias of of officials has many examples of some admitting to such practices and I’m sure you as journalists know exactly of the examples I am referring too, but then and now you will never speak of for the obvious reasons that I have aforementioned…. I will leave you to ponder on this.. A certain Mr Beaton has stated on video somewhere, sometime that he supported the former club known as rangers until he was 21 and then changed to supporting St Mirren I believe … Only a fool, except possibly an educated fool would believe that BS … Again he’s never made any biased decisions in CELTIC v the former rangers … Again, anyone who believes that is living in cloud cuckoo land…. Controversy exists in all aspects of life, and controversy literally means‘TRUTH’ …. AND telling the truth is something that most people are afraid of knowing or recognising for some reason ? Truth is not an option in life but the fundamental basic of life and humanity…. Knowing and telling the truth will ultimately set you free from your intellectual prison walls… yes really 😮
No one is buying Lennon Miller for 10 million.
Muir, as a top referee, should not need to be told by Collum that he made an unprofessional decision. It is not the first incompetent decision he has made in his career as Alison pointed out and evidenced by his inability to notice the most obvious handball from 4 yards away. There are financial repercussions for clubs when this incompetence happens. He needs to lose his job.
Great show guys great talking points views topics banter and opinon as always see you on the next one come on the well come on ye well make sure you like subsribe and share to the football show!!!
VAR Police on the day?… no chance
If clarke doesnt look at nesbit mccowan and lennon millar to add to the squad then he needs to go for sure
Peter trying to defend cheating is some laugh he's done it to Celtic before and he will do it again MUIR should be finished it's as simple as that
Alison do you remember Muir couldn't see a blatant hand ball against caley from 6 feet away and denied Ronny a Treble gees peace hen
"Who do you want in the final Alison? Celtic v Rangers is always a showcase." Nae luck Alison, the weegia mindset eh!
VAR should not be able to overturn an on field decision without conclusive evidence and that simply didn’t exist on this occasion. But, there appears to be no consequences for anyone apart from Celtic.
mr muir lashed his whip didn't even ask ref to have look ( as should be done) and cancelled it.
Guys a cheat it's as simple as that.
Why do they put women on those shows, they know nothing and some of there comments are cringe worthy. Celtic v rangers cup final, i right 😂😂😂
Jesus you could see with the naked eye the ball was well over the line.. but when any Celtic player crosses after a run in a last ditch equalizer and the goal gets dismissed it was not over line completely which it was by the naked eye alone.. well from an Ariel view it looked well over the line even before he got to it.. but it’s Celtic your dealing with here who always moan when they lose a game and you can’t tackle them at parkhead… that’s why they don,t do well in Europe.. for they don,t get there own way… st mirren got denied a stone wall penalty but nothing said.. Scottish football is a survival leauge..
VAR has turned football into a bore fest. Watching a game now is murder.
The huns dont like var cause the dont get a helping hand of the twelve man anymore
They are all genuine mistakes. But always against Celtic. Weak referees.
Still crying about that goal….FFS….Celtic get about 12 fouls a game before they get a yellow card…they get decisions all the time.
Nothing will happen to Muir, they will back him and say it was an honest mistake and he will.learn from it, the usual bull from the authorities.