Catch the MODUS Super Series here every week between Monday – Saturday.
Featuring the Worlds Best Amateur Dart players, over 30 hours per week of live tungsten action, and a prize fund of over 1milliion for 2024
I am Paul the ass Nicholson and I’m ranking dark players today but I’m not doing it blind so the first dark player we’re going to R uh the first dark player we’re going to rank is Kean Barry so what has Keen achieved everything in the youth game almost isn’t a world
Youth champion in the PDC yet but could be by the end of the year but because he hasn’t achieved anything in the senior ranks yet and I say the word yet we’re probably going to have to put him as a c I think I’m not allowed to change these
Am I as I go I might have to change them however the next one is Josh Rock he is a PDC World youth champion and has won a senior event so by talking of that I think you got to put him one level above Keem Barry so what we’re going to do
With Josh rock is we are going to put him at Grade B at this point next player is Michael Smith what hasn’t he achieved he’s won on the floor he’s won on the European Tour the World Series he’s won the world title he’s has won another ranked major so pretty much everything
You can possibly win however hasn’t won anything in a multiple sense yet and I get the feeling that the players that are about to come may have done that so Michael Smith for me will’ll have to be in a okay so not bad for Michael Smith
I’m sure a lot of people would agree with that uh Rob cross two-time European Champion has won back-to-back World Series titles in Australia and New Zealand in the last six or seven months obviously a world champion in 2018 so in the same sort of sense as Michael Smith
I think he’s in air I’m not thinking that he’s reached that super tier level yet but with a match play and a world title two Europeans I think that is about right for the a category next is manlong of Hong Kong a really good talent and we hope based on what we saw
At the world championship and in ban that a big future is ahead however very young in his career and I’m going to have to put him at the bottom tier for now but watch this space Kevin dutes I’m a big fan of he’s done uh things in the
Challenge tour the development tour as well I really really like his compact throw I love his focus and if this was a contest for grading players who can stay through the board he would be super tier and he would be my number one simple as that however based on what he’s
Accomplished in the game so far I’m going to have to put him at the same level as Keen Barry as a safe R Van baral Well Raymond’s been around since I was a kid and I don’t think he Rems me saying that he’s been doing stuff at Lakeside Alexander Palace and the tavern
So he’s played at three World Championship venues and won at two of them so when you consider what he’s done in the game and he’s got the greatness tag because he is one of the great he’s the first person person to go into the Super tier and I don’t think anybody on
Planet DS can disagree with that following that Gary Anderson well again what hasn’t he done I know it’s very much a glass’s half empty statement to say that he hasn’t won the Grand Slam he hasn’t won the European Championship but he’s won pretty much everything else
Hasn’t he and he’s been a BDO great and a PDC great and is still one of the best players in the world he actually set a personal best this week there you go go super tier for him and I’m not going to go against his incredible amount of fans
Because I’m one of them so super tier for Gary Anderson Ricky Evans is somebody I’ve spoken about a lot recently and how I think he’s got to make changes to be the kind of player that he wants to be in the future to be a PDC senior winner he is a former World
Youth finalist and has a great deal to offer the game but where do we put him in this list well I’m going to be harsh on Ricky Evans because I don’t think he’s in Josh Rock’s category of B because he hasn’t won a PDC title yet so
More work to do Ricky you know about this and I know he watches these videos so if you want a bit more motivation rapid I’ve put you in C how can I be somewhat what’s the right word here well I can’t be on the fence can I because
This person is one of my favorite D players and he’s always wearing the right colors it’s Chris dby Master’s Champion multiple time floor winner Premier League player because he hasn’t got a ranked big title yet and I say ranked somewhat Loosely because there are a lot of unranked big events I think
Chris Doby’s best days are ahead of him and he’s not at the same level at this point as a Michael Smith a Rob cross so I’m going to have to put Chris dby in a B I think he’ll be okay with that because he understands that his best
Days are ahead of him Nathan aspel however has won a match player has won plenty of titles on the floor yet to win the European tour though somewhat strange that he’s only made one final as well in Munich in 2023 however someone who’s made two semi-finals at the world championships
And has won at the US starts Masters so for that reason I’m going to put him in the same bracket as Rob cross and Michael Smith just ahead of someone like Chris dorby if he hadn’t won the match play it may be a slightly different story but
For me Nathan as a multiple Premier League player I’m going to have to put him in air alongside robc cross and Michael Phil Taylor super tier moving on Luke Humphries well world number one right now and has won a bucket full of stuff in the last 6 months but it’s not
Just the last 6 months is it it’s European to success over a period of 2 years and for the reason that he’s not got that greatness tag over the course of maybe 20 30 years or even 15 years humph has to go into a because I still
Think that he’s going to get to Super tier in the next 10 years years Michael vanan where do we start well how about we start in 2012 when he won the World Grand Prix beating mvin King in the final that’s where it all began really I know he won the World Masters before
That as a kid and he had his own little Luke ller moment but he was great before that he was great after that but became the player that he is now from 2012 until now does he have greatness in him yes has he always had it pretty much in
My eyes and he always will that’s why he’s in the super tier Adrien Lewis a multiple world champion a UK open champion and a European Champion don’t forget that one when he won that European Championship he was the best player in that tournament by an absolute
Mile and had a great doart shirt in that tournament as well so look back at that one I love this guy contrary to what people think because of our spot at the World Cup in 2012 one of the nicest people in the world and this is probably
Going to be the hardest decision of everything in this one does he go in the super tier or does he go in the A8 because it depends on whether he’s going to offer more to the ranked game in the future we just don’t know and for that
Reason he goes in a Steven bunding is someone I’ve known since 1999 when he was 16-year-old kid playing for Mery side County he’s only just won his biggest PDC title at the Masters and many congratulations to him for doing that where do we put Steven bunting in
This list he hasn’t won a great deal of PDC titles in the last 10 years but he’s won a few of them I don’t think you can put him in the same bracket as Adrien Lewis or Luke Humphries or Nathan aspel Rob Cross or Michael Smith but can you
Put him alongside someone like Chris dby who’s also won the Masters and a similar amount of flaw titles I think yes so we’re going to put bonding in B Dimitri venberg is a world match player Champion where do we put this guy I mean he hasn’t won a European to a tight leader
He’s won World Series events and isn’t it amazing how many players of this sort of level have won some events from certain places but they haven’t won something that’s perceived as easier always known as a stage player not so much a floor player who do we put him
Alongside I think it’s fairly easy a onetime major champion in the PDC you got to put him alongside bunting Rock and dby Scott Williams one of the most entertaining players on the circuit and has got a great sock collection trust me semi-finalist at the world championship recently and is only just starting to
Find out what kind of player he can possibly be has not got a great deal of titles but he has got a PDC title to his name when he didn’t have his card he’s part of an exclusive club with Christopher tyy and Joel minin in the
Fact that he has won a title without toour privileges guaranteed I think we have to put him next to the likes of Evans duut and Kean Barry now I’m not doing him a disservice here but can we put him alongside the lakes of Vandenburg bunting dby well I would put him alongside a
Josh Rock but I see Josh as maybe just a little bit further ahead of him it’s such a small Gap but I’m going to have to put Scott Williams in SE Eric Bristol where do we start one of the people who gave us all of this we go back 50 years
To the mid ’70s we had the indoor league in Yorkshire we had so many people playing on that but when we started getting World Championships broadcast in 1978 who stood up and said this sport is just a little bit special it was Eric Bristol five world five World titles and
The greatness of the man who we will unfortunately never see again and someone who I had a somewhat checkered relationship with my life but one of the best things about Eric is what he did for our Sport and he was so D smart maybe smarter than than anybody who will
Ever live he’s got to be super tier and you know why GN price a great great player I’m a big fan of him you might not be but I’m sure by the end of his career you will be it’s as simple as that not everybody’s made the same so
Understand that he’s not going to follow the Prototype of what a d player should be he wants to be himself and he’s a great player not quite in the super tier category but as a world champion and a three-time grand slam champion I think you’ve got to put him in here Jonathan
Clayton sorry Johnny this is a tough one as much as a Premier League champion and a Grand Prix Champion should probably be in category a I wish there was an ear minus column here because do I see him ahead of an Ethan aspinal see him on a
Pod do I see him on the same level as a Luke Humphrey Adrien Lewis no but can I put him in B I don’t think I can so he’s going to have to go in a d David chisel how many people in this world can call
Him David maybe one or two and I don’t think I’m one of them so Dave chisnell hasn’t won a big ranked event yet and I’m sure he’s sick of people talking about it so what has he won an awful lot of titles 20 PDC titles was my last
Count it might even be more than that by now so it’s harsh not to put him in ear but until he wins that big one or a world title I’m afraid he’s going to have to go in B Joe Cullen a Masters champion and obviously has one on the
Floor and one at the European tour and he’s beaten Michael vanan in a couple of finals on the European tour when he was dominant as well just take note of that Joe Cullen has to go in the category the same as Dave chisel it’s as simple as that you can’t possibly put him
Alongside Ricky Evans Scott Williams Kevin dutes and Keane Barry but you can you put him in air I’m not sure we can so it’s going to have to be the same as Bunting and Doby former Masters champion has to go in B Lisa Ashton it’s about
Time we got to girl up here isn’t it four-time ladies Champion she’s won pretty much everything you can win in the ladies game apart from the PDC World match play so she could possibly win that in the future and she could even get more World titles in the bank as
Well just depends what Lisa wants to do with her career from the ladies Gamers perspective there aren’t many better in fact only Trina GLI has won more World titles so for that reason super tier Felisa Ashton Paul limb ooh maybe want to keep that in that was quite quite a
Nice moment maybe maybe he’s present Paul Lim is one of the most iconic people in our sport since the 1980s and for what he’s done not just in a title sense in the far e because he’s one of the best soft tip players of all time as well alongside the likes of
Kitma and Gates that may not come into other people’s thinking but super TI for me is about what you’ve done for the game as a whole can we put Paul alongside Ashton the likes of vanwin Bristol Taylor Anderson and R van baral some people might say this is
Controversial but for what he’s done over the course of the last 40 years as a dark player worldwide and is continuing to do his importance cannot be measured he’s a super tier player maybe he’s just a super tier person Peter Wright has won an awful lot and
Has had stages in his career started in the ’90s seen as someone who did well to make Lakeside fast forward 30 years he becomes one of the best players that we’ve ever seen if you’re putting Gary Anderson in the super tier with two World titles and what he’s won you have
To put Peter Wright in the same category I’m sorry but I’m not going to be controversial here and put him in a different category to Gary two-time world champion you’s got to be up there Steve Beaton is a super tier great in my opinion but has he done as much for the
Game as Paul limb has it’s arguable however the amount of PDC titles that Steve has had I think he would admit that maybe he should have had a few more one of my favorite people that I’ve ever met have ever played against and I’m going to be completely selfish here just
Like anybody who was sitting in this seat would be do you put him alongside the likes of Nathan Asal rck cross Michael Smith of course you do he won the Le exite in 96 Will O Conor has made a world cup fin and has won one PDC
Title I love watching him play and he’s a nightmare opponent for anybody where do you put him in this list it’s simple you put him in either B or C this is an in betweeny for me because he hasn’t done as much as see Doby or a Joe Cullen
But he’s done more than the likes of dutes Williams and Keen Barry so I’m going to be generous to Mr okona and I’m going to put him in B Gabriel Clemens has not won a PDC title yet so for me this is fairly simple even though he’s
Made a semi-final of a world he has to be SI can anybody find a Pokemon around here oh that’s right Pikachu rard P treko has won the German darts championship in the last six months I’m still putting him in the same category as Gabriel Clemens even though he’s won
A title because I still think that the semi-final of the world and that European tour title and the young nature of Pikachu’s career cancel themselves out so Ricardo petko is in now we’re getting interesting with Luke liter aren’t we now we can’t get too carried away he’s only been playing players
Championships for two days by the time this is filmed he’s played in two World Series events and one world championship but has got multiple titles already where do you put him you might think this is crazy but I’m going to put him in B he’s not anywhere near his legacy
Yet so why do we do this in about 15 years time for now he’s in B last but not least fall and sherik what has she done for the game an awful lot and an awful lot for the ladies game as well don’t forget that the women’s series
Pretty much came off the back of 2019 so would that have happened if it hadn’t been for that success she has won an awful lot in her career and done things at the Grand Slam the world championship and other places as well however we need to be realistic in this regard she has
Not won a World title she has not won a PDC ranked title overall because let’s face it the PDC titles are open to both categories so where do you put Fallen sherik I’m afraid she has to go in C and I think that’s fair that’s me done I’ve
Ranked all these dark players whether you agree or disagree I don’t personally care cuz they’re my opinion so why don’t you ever a go
19 Comments
Very enjoyable watch this
Awesome video ! Thanks you Paul Nicholson.
Great video that. Nicholson always offers brilliant insight. But Clayton and Lim are too high here. Lim is a legend for sure but never a super tier player. Clayton should be a tier lower as well.
If were going on standard and won,,, Beaton is deffo not A Lisa is deffo defoo not top
Adrian Lewis one tier up
We’re on earth is James the machine wade??🙁
Very good watch this. Nicho really seems like a top lad, and sure knows a lot about darts
I always love to listen to Paul, one of the very best experts in the game. His thinking, reasoning and his foresight are absolutly amazing 💪🏼
Why Clemens lower than O'Connor?
Paul Nicholson
Decent darts player
Annoying commentator
Asp hasn't won a world title how can he be the same as Cross or Humphries?
Will littler be in PDC youth? I’m not sure how it works.
I would like to suggest a series “what doesn’t Nicho know?”
The guy has information about every subject 😂 deffo someone you’d want on your pub quiz team
Not putting the Adonis in S tier is unforgivable 😢 it’s Stevie B
Great watch …… but as said where’s Wade ??…… love listening to Paul…… so knowledgeable I look forward to the day the big bucks are paid and he is transferred to sky
Paul is always a fascinating listen, the only one of these I strongly disagree with is Dimi, if you’re going to put Nathan in A because he won the matchplay then imo you need to put Dimi there too. Regardless though, love Paul and could listen to him talk darts all day
Taylors not a S Nico he is in his own bracket
Lewis definitely supertier, especially if wright it is in there
Ur crazy for putting Luke littler in b tier he’s beat MVG and RVB lolll