St. Johns County commissioners voted unanimously this week to reject two proposals for World Golf Village, following major new developments that could influence the property’s future.
The decision came after county staff revealed that the new owner of the Renaissance St. Augustine Resort —a privately owned Marriott property—plans a comprehensive $20 million renovation.
County staff said the investment strengthens the county’s negotiating position regarding its adjacent parcels, including the closed Hall of Fame and IMAX theater buildings.
The Renaissance Hotel in World Golf Village. (Google Maps)
Commissioners emphasized that the hotel renovation represents a major private-sector boost that could enhance any future redevelopment at World Golf Village.
“We have this $20 million private sector gift that just got dropped off in our lap,” Commissioner Christian Whitehurst said in advocating for a reset. “Which strengthens our ability to negotiate. This is a gift. This is private sector, not taxpayer money. So what we’re doing is we’re wiping the slate clean. We’re going to start from scratch with a strengthened position to negotitate.”
The county owns surrounding land and buildings that could be affected by future redevelopment, including the Hall of Fame and IMAX theater.
Previously, the county had advanced two proposals to the second phase of its public-private partnership process. One envisioned a theme-park style plan featuring golf, mini-golf, a virtual reality golf lounge, wellness-focused amenities, and upgrades to the IMAX and Hall of Fame buildings. The other proposed a mixed-use development with medical facilities, senior living, retail, restaurants, and commercial space.
The current World Golf Village complex.
Both proposals faced complexities stemming from the property’s multi-owner status. St. Johns County holds some parcels, the World Golf Foundation owns other sections, and private developers control the golf course.
A lawsuit filed by the World Golf Foundation challenges land-use restrictions that require parts of World Golf Village to remain dedicated to the Hall of Fame, PGA Productions, an IMAX or similar attraction, and an 18-hole golf course for the next 25 years.
The foundation has argued that the restrictions severely limits the property’s marketability, and the case is playing out in court.
The county wants to reevaluate its position. (Wikimedia Commons)
The BCC voted to hold moderated negotiations with all property stakeholders to address the deed restrictions.
While the current proposals are officially rejected, staff emphasized that no final action has been taken regarding the county-owned parcels themselves.
