The Dallas Mavericks face a tough decision for their 2025-26 starting lineup. With D’Angelo Russell, Cooper Flagg, Anthony Davis, and Dereck Lively II already in place, the final spot comes down to Klay Thompson or P.J. Washington. Both players bring unique strengths, but the Mavs’ shooting struggles from last season (32.1% from three in the final two months) could force their hand. Should they prioritize Thompson’s elite shooting to space the floor for Davis, or stick with Washington’s versatility and rebounding? We break down the pros and cons of each option, analyze the impact on the team’s spacing and defense, and predict Jason Kidd’s likely choice. Don’t miss this in-depth analysis of the Mavericks’ lineup conundrum and what it means for their championship aspirations next season!
The Dallas Mavericks are facing a pivotal dilemma. Their opening night starting five could hinge on a contentious choice between two elite talents. With D’Angelo Russell, Cooper Flag, Anthony Davis, and Derek Lively II locked in. The final spot in the lineup will likely go to either Klay Thompson or PJ Washington. A decision that could redefine the team’s future. While both players deserve a starting role, the Mavs glaring three-point shooting issue may force a split decision that leaves fans scratching their heads. But here’s where it gets controversial. The team’s 32.1% shooting from deep last season, 24th in the NBA could push them to bench Washington, despite his proven track record. At 27, Washington is a dynamic wing with a lucrative 4-year contract extension. Yet, his lack of consistent three-point production might cost him the starting spot. Thompson, on the other hand, is a lethal shooter who averaged 39.1% from beyond the ark last year, making him a logical choice for the role. The Mavs can’t go wrong either way. Both players will see significant minutes regardless of the starting decision. But the core of the debate lies in spacing. Thompson’s higher volume shooting and offball movement would create ideal spacing for Davis, who struggles from deep, 29.6% career three-point rate. If Washington is forced to guard the perimeter, he might be isolated, leaving Davis vulnerable to heavy help defense. This is the part most people miss. The Mavs need shooters not just to score, but to protect their big men. While Washington has been the team’s starting four since the 2024 trade deadline, Jason Kidd may prioritize immediate improvement over long-term potential. A lineup featuring Washington, Flag, Davis, and Lively 2 would be dominant defensively, but it lacks the necessary shooting to sustain success. Thompson’s ability to stretch the floor and create space for Davis could be the difference between a playoff contender and a mid-tier team. And this is the part most people miss. The Mavs decision isn’t just about talent, it’s about strategy. Thompson’s consistency and fit with the system might make him the safer choice, even if Washington is objectively better. The real question is, should the Mavs prioritize short-term fixes or long-term growth? What would you choose? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
