Prime Aaron Rodgers Vs Current Patrick Mahomes? š¤ #nfl #football #goat
Credit to @TheFacilityonFS1 for the discussion.
prime Rogers or Kar Mahomes i’m taking Prime Aaron Rogers the greatest we’ve ever seen and I don’t care nothing about no Super Bowls none of that talk about playing the game of football prime Aaron Rodgers was coldblooded we talking about fourtime MVP that means you are the best player in the National Football League he has four of them remember Andy Reid outside of Patrick Mahomes went to four straight conference championship games if Aaron Rogers is so great how y’all say he is in his prime how is it possible for you to only have one Super Bowl appearance that’s embarrassing and Big Ben I don’t respect players that talk about greats a certain way and you have nowhere the type of success they
39 Comments
Yall are high if you think Rodgers over Mahomes.
Mahomes has been to 5 times the amount of Super Bowls as Rodgers and heās not 30 years old yet.
And if āsuper bowls donāt matterā youāre an idiot.
If you are bringing up Andy Reid then how come we never have that argument for a Dan Marino that Don Shula win 3 SBs before Dan got there?? The Packers was SB contenders at the end of farve career and ARod took over they won a few year later and havenāt won since
š§ š
Mahomes all day. Iām getting at least an mvp season making the afc or Super Bowl appearance.
Mahomes I want a qb that can actually play Great in the Clutch AR12 still great tho šÆšÆšÆ
James Jones is biased af, I wonder why…..
Donāt care about super wins? Brady had three game winnings drives in three super bowls. Rodgersās couldnāt even make it back to a second one. James jones was mid and his takes are mid
Shady only been to 1 superbowl… and didnt even play
Ben went to 3 superbowls and won 2
Rodgerās is one of the best weāve ever seen throw a football and if you think less then frankly you just donāt know ball. Lions fan here as well.
If aaron had all the protection pattty got now from the league shidd his ahhh easily have 5 chips
Rodgers not top 5
If prime Rodgers was just a bit more faster and healthy throughout his career and didnt sit on the bench for 3 years with a tad bit more players on the squad (some of those years you cant really ask for more and he won it them as well) then people would have him in a top 3 qb all time conversation.
Patrick Mahomes any time, any place
Statistically, itās Rodgers every way shape and form. Accolades, Mahomes in my opinion just edges out Rodgers because he has two more rings. But people have to remember that he has won 4 MVPs with two being in a row is an amazing and rare feat. Favre is in the hall of fame with 1 Super Bowl and only 3 MVPs (although they were all won in a row). Meanwhile there could be a real possibility that if both qbs had to retire today and have their careers judged, one is going before the other and itās not Mahomes. More rings doesnāt necessarily mean he is guaranteed first ballot. I personally think there will be a debate one day that, similarly to Eli Manning, was Mahomes really the key to winning the Super Bowls and being regular season beasts or was it a top 5 defense that kept it rolling. If anything Mahomesā past 2 seasons have felt very Eli Manning like and that Mahomes is better than him enough to make progress on more playoff runs.
Super Bowls may not mean everything but to say they mean nothing is insane.
Rodgers. All day every day. People forget so easy lol most talented qb of all time
All these morons in the comments forget that winning a Super Bowl is a TEAM ACCOMPLISHMENT! Not an individual one! Prime Aaron Rodgers in Andy Reidās team wouldāve won 3 Super Bowls in 3 years instead of 5 years
He is just trying bait people to leave comments is all.
Shady team hopped for his rings now he uses it against everyone else
i mean you could make the conversation that rodgersā wasnāt even a top 3 qb of his era
Iām sorry mahomes 5,000 yard mvp season is better than any season in Rodgerās prime but last year you give Aronās prime the win because Pats numbers where down
Glazerrr
Mahomes "prime" is 7 straight AFC championships, 5 Superbowl appearances, 3 time Champion, and 2 time MVP and Superbowl MVP. That comparison isnt even close. Rodgers is a 4x MVP, but 3 of his 4 MVPs came after his "prime". Hes better now than he was from 05-11, taking a full 7 years to get that first MVP and championship (carried by Clay Matthews). Not to mention he had a SLEW of recievers his whole career and never touched 5000.
MVP doesnāt necessary mean youāre the best player in the league. It means youre the most valuable player to your teams success
Aaron Rodgers doesn't deserve 4 mvps
James jones takes & opinions arenāt even relevant anymore with how biased he is. Rodgers was good during his prime but nowhere near Mahomes. Not even close
I know rings and rings but come on now we gotta stop making it seem like just because you do not have a ring or only have a certain amount that takes away of you being a great football player. shady let me ask you this if you are so great Mr. crazy work how come you never been to a Super Bowl and if you have, you didnāt play no part of winning it. and I am an Eagles fan, but letās stop.
I know rings and rings but come on now we gotta stop making it seem like just because you do not have a ring or only have a certain amount that takes away of you being a great football player. shady let me ask you this if you are so great Mr. crazy work how come you never been to a Super Bowl and if you have, you didnāt play no part of winning it. and I am an Eagles fan, but letās stop.
Mccoy says dont talk on players better then you also listen to me talk bout them
Shady acting like he's accomplished more than Big Ben is the funniest thing I've heard all year
I think Rodgers is the Michael Jordan of Football.
The problem is the generation weāre living in. Only reason people choose mahomes over Rodgers is simply because their feelings are hurt and canāt put that fact around their brains. They cry about everything politics, life, opinions, they canāt separate reality and instead lie to themselves to avoid reality
Most talented = Rogers, Marino
Most accomplished = Brady
Mahomes is a combo of those above to a certain degree
What people need to realize is for team success, you need a general..rogers is a bad leader
I don't even think this is close. Malhomes all day, only better QB ever is Brady.
Rodgers most overrated ever
Aaron Rodgers has way more individual awards then mahomes and will at the end of mahomes career as an individual mahomes canāt fuck with prime Rodgers he just had an mvp season 4 yrs ago but mahomes has better team success
Team success has nothing to do with being a better player if thatās the case yāall sayin Brock purify is better than Allen and Lamar cause he went to the Super Bowl hell nah
Lamar has two and yāall keep saying but no Superbowl